Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending May 31st 2008

Posted Mon 26 May 2008 7:14PM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK
The speculation was correct. Despite (or perhaps because of) the release of debut album 'We Started Nothing', the Ting Tings were unable to hold off the challenge of the newly released 'Take A Bow' from Rihanna, the net result being a straight swap of last weeks Top 2 singles.

Rihanna was of course further helped by the addition of physical sales for her single and her reward is her second Number One single (the first - 'Umbrella' - still hovers around the bottom end of the singles chart and is at Number 73 this week as if in sympathy).

'Take A Bow' is one of several brand new tracks that are set to appear on a "special edition" re-release of the 'Good Girl Gone Bad Album'. On the podcast last week I marvelled out loud as to why we as music buyers seem to accept such stunts given that it effectively amounts to ripping off those who snapped up the album first time around. What better way of showing contempt for your fans than turning around and enhancing an existing album with new material, as if to say "thanks for your loyalty, we're sure you won't mind forking out again for material you already own just to own some extra tracks". Admittedly it is these days a simple matter just to buy the additional material as single downloads if you are so inclined, but this still does not change the fact that new buyers of the Special Edition will receive more for their money than loyal purchasers who first picked up the album last summer.

Maybe I am showing my age, but treating fans with such contempt used to be taboo. Back in 1990 the band James released their first major label album 'Gold Mother' only to re-package it a year later with the hit single 'Sit Down' added to the tracklisting. To avoid a backlash, the label arranged a new for old swap deal, allowing buyers to trade in their original versions for the new one should they so desire. Back then it was responsible marketing, now in the 21st century contriving a way to persuade people to pay for the same product twice is considered a viable money spinner.

Back to the Ting Tings and the bitter pill of becoming the first act since last Christmas to spend just a week at the top is almost certainly sweetened by the presence of 'We Started Nothing' at the very top of the album chart. As a direct result its most notable tracks also make their singles chart debut. First of all there is the first ever chart appearance of their last single 'Great DJ' which arrives at Number 33, the album track unfettered by the packaging violations which caused it to forfeit a chart placing when first made available back in March. Also new is the international single hit 'Shut Up And Let Me Go', best known to people here as the music from the latest iPod TV commercials, the track registering at Number 49.

The only other new Top 10 arrival is 'Warwick Avenue' from Duffy which continues its upwards momentum with a 13-7 climb. This is its last week as a download only single, the addition of physical sales should neatly give the lady from the valleys her second Top 5 hit. 

Movement in the Top 20 is largely confined to the future releases which are still moving ever closer to penetrating the Top 10. 'Closer' from Ne-Yo (out June 30) rebounds from its surprising reverse last week to advance to Number 12, 'Love Song' from Sara Bareilles (June 2) moves 23-17 whilst 'I Can Be' from Taio Cruz skips 30-19 ahead of its physical release this week (May 26).

One track that appears to have missed altogether however is 'Party People' from Nelly and Fergie which went physical this week but which can only manage a two place rise to Number 14 off the back. For a single that was supposed to be Nelly's big comeback it has underachieved to say the last. Aside from his small vocal contribution to all-star Number One hit 'Nasty Girl' in 2006, the US rapper has not had a Top 10 hit since 'N Dey Say' climbed to Number 6 in June 2005.

In a neat coincidence the always appealing Alphabeat manage to occupy two consecutive chart places this week. Previous hit 'Fascination' continues its slow burnout by holding firm at Number 22, just outselling new single 'Ten Thousand Nights' which lands at Number 23 after download sales, one week ahead of its physical release. It all sets up nicely for the release of debut album 'This Is Alphabeat' which hits the stores on June 2.

Also new inside the Top 30 are the long awaited comeback singles from two acts who have already written their fair share of classics. Winning the mini race for now are The Fratelliswhose task of following up acclaimed debut album 'Costello Music' begins this week. Ahead of new album 'Here We Stand' comes new single 'Mistress Mabel', a new entry at Number 27 thanks to download sales. The single is a reassuring reminder than they have lost none of the traits that made their previous singles such barnstorming classics, a thundering guitar riff backing an instantly hummable barroom stormer with the requisite killer chorus. The single goes physical this week although I'm doubtful of its abilities to gatecrash the Top 10. Judge for yourselves below. 

New in at Number 28 are the band who are in the rather frustrating position of being responsible for one of the biggest and most acclaimed hits of 2007 without most people being aware. With Mark Ronson and Amy Winehouse having elevated their song 'Valerie' to the status of a classic, the Zutons are faced with reminding the world just who it was who recorded the song in the first place. Their new single, also from a forthcoming new album, is 'Always Right Behind You' in which they conjure up the ghosts of Status Quo circa 1977 and nick the title of "best pub rock singalong track of the week" from the Fratellis by the thinnest of margins. In common with their Glaswegian rivals, the band arrive on digital sales with physicals to be added to the mix next week. Place your bets then, which one will end up charting higher in seven days time?

The retro-dance craze initiated by 'Toca's Miracle' and 'Something Good' looks set to spawn some more minor hits before the month is out. Arriving in the Top 40 at Number 34 is a 2008 remix of 'Disco's Revenge' from Gusto. Originally a Top 10 single in early 1996, the track appears to be one of those long-forgotten guilty pleasures which has hardly merited a mention since its first release and yet which has veteran clubbers going misty eyed at the memories of it whenever the new version is brought up. As the title suggests, the track is based heavily around a sample from an old disco track, namely 'Groovin You' by Harvey Mason which was itself never a hit. The Gusto track is joined by a rather more surprising twin, 'Rhythm Is A Dancer' from Snap which has turned into a spontaneous hit in 2008 thanks to its use in TV commercials for Drench spring water. Originally released in 1992, the track spent six weeks at the top of the singles chart and in pop terms became the defining sound of the summer of that year. It isn't the first time the track has reappeared on the chart since, a remix by CJ Stone having reached Number 17 back in 2003.

Finally for this week Great Britain's spectacular achievement in coming joint last in the scoring at the Eurovision Song Contest is neatly rounded off by the appearance of our entry 'Even If' from Andy Abraham at the rather lowly position of Number 67. Whilst you will see plenty of hand-wringing and grumbling over the result and the usual whining about Eastern Europe block voting in other places, I will simply maintain that Britain's continual failure to live up to our own high standards in the contest has little to do with regional politics and everything to do with our continual insistence on submitting songs that are both utterly useless and sadly indicative of a woeful ignorance of European musical tastes. Place all the blame for that on the people at the BBC responsible for drawing up the song shortlist. Replacing them with people who actually know something about music cannot come a moment too soon. Instead let us speculate which of the other entries will "do a Verka" and invade the singles chart next week in the wake of Saturday's broadcast. Early indications are that the third place Greek entry 'Secret Combination' which picked up the maximum 12 points from British voters is the one storming ahead in online sales.

52 Comments

1. Rich -
I think Zutons will go higher - I like the fact that it reminds me of Wizard.

I bought the Bosnia-Herz (Tim Burton's washingline song) and am tempted by Armenia and even the non qualifying Bulgarian Pendulumesque entry. Andy Ambrahms would ahve got more points with that song in the 70s but as it stands it's really out of touch with the kind of people that tend to vote.

May I suggest using one artist and just choosing the song next year so that it's less of a popularity contest and more, you know, a song contest...

2. Anthony -
Why the sudden appearence at #60 of Defying Gravity by Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth? It's from a four year old musical called Wicked. Very odd!

Also strange how Ashlee Simpson and Royworld only crawled up the chart on physical release. Their CD releases were basically a waste of time.

3. grumpyoldgit.com -
The Andy Abraham song reminded me of the Sydney Youngblood song of 1989 "If Only I Could". It wasn't a bad song and really deserved to do better despite what James thinks. I personally think that rather than bring songs into the equation, each Country should just sit down and vote for whichever other Country that they like the best and rename the contest the "Eurovision this is the bestest ever Country" contest. A lot less hassle don't you think? Keep up the good work James.

4. minardifan -
I agree with Jon B, I thought it sounded like If Only I Could! Such a shame Andy only charted at no.67 - I can't remember the last time a UK Eurovision entry failed to make the top 40 (any ideas anyone?). It doesn't matter what sort of song we put in to Eurvision(ballad, rap, UK soul, cheesy nonsense, sultry female), nothing works. Time to pull out of this Eastern European-dominated contest, I think.

5. Haris -
I think England has the power to send someone like Shakira or Kylie and wipe out the competition. "My Secret Combination" is addictive, as well as "Hero" and Israel's Boaz. Dima's "Believe" is quite nice too but I would prefer to hear it by Antony & The Johnsons.

6. Zabija -
Couple of Points,

i agree the Music industry does not have a clue how to treat it's consumers. In the 'new digital age', they still insist on force feeding us outdated product. The Re packaging of Albums in Special edition formats (with an extra track or 2) continues to Insult and abuse the avarage music buyer. This is why i voted with my Pocket.

Down at my local Private Torrent Site, i can get the Rihanna album in Mp3 (198kbs, Vo, V2 or 320kbs) Wav, flac, ape or Acc, with Cover scans, Release info, image files and a Bunch of People who leave helpful coments about the Release. I Would Happily pay for that!

Anyway, moving on. I watched the Eurovision in Laughter as we Failed again! Of course their is gonna be Political voting, always has been. But look at the Countries we are up against and then look at the Content of their Charts. The Songs we Submit just do not appeal to Scandinavia or Eastern Europe! I should know, i live in Poland (Joint last, i think?) My ears are Bleeding!

7. AJG -
A couple of strange facts this week - 16 climbers, which must be the highest for some considerable time, and every single new entry last week (with the obvious exception of Ting Tings) climbed - when was the last time that happened?

8. Borza -
In answer to your query, I think I am right in saying that the last UK entry that failed to reach the top 40 was "Why do I always get it wrong" for Live Report back in 1989. It finished second and is not a bad song at all. I thought the Eurovision was entertaining as ever and contrary to all the UK whinging, Russia deserved their victory as they got points from the vast majority of the other 42 nations. The winning song was produced by Timbaland, sung by an artist who had won a World Music Award for the last 3 years and featured a World Figure Skating Champion and a famous violinist. A binman who finished second in X Factor doesn't really compare!

9. Yahoo! Music User -
Absolutely agree with Borza above. Dima Bilan thoroughly deserved to win Eurovision and no doubt will become a future hit once digitally available. The UK is so out of touch with what makes a potential winning song at eurovision and really should spend more time observing the other countries and what is popular. As for poor Andy i can't see him surviving for much longer and maybe he should go back to being a binman.

10. Chig -
I've just returned today from Eurovision week in Belgrade, where the UK delegation (not Great Britain and not England) pretty much treated the contest with contempt. They didn't produce any press packs or bring any CDs of Andy's single, to give out to the hundreds of international journalists (and fans) who were there for a fortnight. They didn't have any party or function to promote the UK either, as they have done in recent years. Other countries are throwing money at their entries, to get media coverage, and it works. If you don't promote the song, you don't get written about. It's almost as if the BBC did it on purpose......

And yes, it is the lowest chart placing for the UK's Eurovision single since Live Report iin 1989.

11. Nick -
The voting in Eurovision is often biased, but by and large good songs got reasonable votes (with a few exceptions, notably Germany and Sweden). Ukraine was my favourite and it came second. I thought Norway and Israel were great and they came in the top 10. Andy Abrams song just wasn't up to it. It didn't deserve to come last but it didn't deserve a top 10 placing either.

Commentators always seems to forget that each country can only give marks to 10 out of 24 countries. Theoretically every country could place the UK 11th out of 25 and it would get nul points. How fair is that?

Great weekly column James. I love chart and sales facts. Do you know where "Great DJ" would have charted first time round if it had been eligible for the charts?

12. Yahoo! Music User -
Well of course "My Secret Combination" is ahead in sales. It's the only one of this year's songs available on iTunes!

If I'm not mistaken "4 Minutes" has just spent its 10th week inside the top 10. Unless it drops 8 places next week, it will be Madonna's longest stay in the top 10 ever!

The UK is bitter as ever about Eurovision. At the end of the day, the countries in the top 3 received votes from just about every other country in the competition. That's not political voting, it's popular songs.

13. DS -
hmv555- are either Kylie or Shakira English??

14. this charming man -
I have no interest whatsoever in the Eurovision Song Contest, or the so-called Talent Shows such as X Factor, where Andy Abraham came second, I just don't think it's fair to define him by his former/future profession in a derogatory way (see 8 and 9). I am sure that the people who left these comments are high-flying, City workers, with a slightly unhealthy liking for cheesy pop, but does this authorise them to be so offensive of other supposedly lower professions?
This is a place where music and chart lovers blab about chart positions, and I love it, let's leave out this sort of comments, shall we?
On a lighter note, that Rihanna song is really rubbish, a real shame after such a good start of the year for number ones.

15. Yahoo! Music User -
The Zutons are so gonna beat The Fratellies! I think it would be like Oasis Vs Blur all over again! (Maybe not). Anyway, I don't think Rhianna derserves another number one but naything to knock the putrid Ting Tings off the top! These are my top 5 for next week:
#1-Duffy-Warwick Avenue
#2-The Zutons-ALways Right Behind You
#3-The Fratellies-Mistress Mabel
#4-Rhianna-Take A Bow
#5-The Ting Tings-That's Not My Name

16. Zabija -
@DS: I May be Wrong, but i dont think it matters where the Performer is From, i thought it was all down to the Writers nationality? Hence the eurovision SONG Contest?

17. Yahoo! Music User -
Just another thing, DS, Kylie's Australlian and Shakira's Spanish. (I think!)

18. Yahoo! Music User -
Sorry for double posting (prays it's allowed) but I forget Coldpaly deserve to shoot up in the top 5 instead of the Ting Tings. If I made the charts, I'd give Coldplay number one, they've had so much sucsess and they really deserve it!

19. Yahoo! Music User -
I'm bored so I'm posting again! I think we need an indie band to represent Eurovision. Maybe Kaiser Cheifs or Artic Monkeys. I got the idea from MTV2's Flux Me, I'm Famous. Anyone lese got any ideas?

20. Yahoo! Music User -
Great column James, always my first point of call on a Sunday evening. Not much more to add apartfrom thanks from a mad chart watcher since the age of 6, when the first 7" vinyl I bought was the late great Laura Branigans Gloria! (which reached no.6 uk if I'm not mistaken. Oh and all hail the return of the best band in the world and living memory "COLDPLAY" I am beside myself with joy that the album is only days away!!!
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Take That Eurovision!

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 10:42AM GMT

Dotmusic - Gary Barlow to write 2010 theme tune? More »

More News Stories