Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending January 31st 2009

Posted Mon 26 Jan 2009 11:24AM GMT by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

I'm a little late appearing this week as I've been distracted listening to the White Lies album on Spotify, enjoying it enormously until I realised that the "who do they sound like" mental stroll was leading me down the darkened alley labelled Cock Robin. Nonetheless the boys from West London do good this week, seeing debut long player 'To Lose My Life' soar to the top of the album chart to prove once and for all that there are some advantages to unleashing hot new product in a January lull. Their success on the grown up chart is all the more impressive given that it comes without any high profile singles chart appearances. The title track from the album still languishes lower down the Top 40, rising just one place to Number 34 this week. The implication there is clear - they have tapped in to an eager audience of fans who were willing to snatch their CD off the shelves the moment it appeared, bypassing the cherry-picking market altogether. I'm still hopeful that they can turn this into singles success at some stage however, they deserve the larger audience that comes with hit singles and mainstream airplay.

The top end of the singles chart is pretty much as we expected, the battle between Lady Gaga and Kid Cudi extending to a second week. Victory spoils quite rightly go to the underdressed one as 'Just Dance' retains its singles crown for a third week running. She does it with another impressively strong sale, selling in excess of 70,000 copies for the second week in succession. As you may have heard me mention on the podcast last week, this level of sales is incredibly impressive for January and her totals to date makes 'Just Dance' one of the fastest selling January releases of the decade. Four years ago this week, Ciara was topping the chart after selling just 21,000 copies of 'Goodies'. 'Just Dance' by contrast has now shifted a quarter of a million copies in its four weeks on sale.

Meanwhile what is theoretically Lady Gaga's next single 'Poker Face' continues to race ahead of all plans, moving four places to Number 26 and surely leaving her label on the horns of an awkward dilemma. If they wait too long before pushing it as her next hit, it could well have been and gone from the singles chart already. Yet with 'Just Dance' selling so strongly and surely set for a slow and graceful burnout any attempt to move on to a different track too soon is likely to be ignored by an enraptured public.

Honours for the biggest chart climb of the week go to Tinchy Stryder and Taio Cruz who soar 39-3 with 'Take Me Back'. As I mentioned last week, the single had previously charted thanks to sales of two dance mixes alone, this rocket to mainstream stardom coming after the full single package was made available along with a more commercial friendly radio edit. Also climbing into the Top 10 this week is Pink who moves 26-9 with the now fully released 'Sober'. The second single from her album 'Funhouse', the single sees her bring the unexpected once more, ploughing a refreshing alt-rock furrow to wonderful effect.

Also pleasingly on the rise is Alesha Dixon who rises to Number 13 with dreamy ballad 'Breathe Slow', a track she debuted live on the River Thames on new years eve. A track designed to show off her vocal strengths and a world away from the happy go lucky party vibe of 'The Boy Does Nothing', the single is a clever way of stating her case as a versatile and talented singer. A part of me still misses her days as part of Mis-Teeq when all their songs were built around the moment when stepped forward and let rip with a thousand mile an hour ragga toast ("My time, show time, hook line, let 's roll, let's drive...").

To find the highest new entry of the week we have to look as far down as Number 20 and the arrival of 'Ulysses', the brand new single from the returning Franz Ferdinand. It is the first single from their new album 'Tonight: Franz Ferdinand' which hits the shops properly this week and which I suspect may well distract from the chart potential of the single itself. 'Ulysses' follows the usual Franz Ferdinand formula to welcome effect, based around a central guitar riff which not only drives the rhythm of the song but which acts almost like a complementary vocal line. Enormously catchy and incredibly worthwhile.

Another new arrival is at Number 23. 'Tonight' is a brand new track from Jay Sean, specially recorded for a deluxe re-release of his 2008 album 'My Own Way', its chart appearance coming after its predecessor 'Stay' limped to a rather miserable Number 59 in July last year. The aim with this new single is to launch him in the US market, hence the presence of Lil' Wayne on the single to give it that extra bit of appeal Stateside.

Bringing up the rear at Number 37 is the third and final new entry of the week, 'Blood Bank' by Bon Iver. The group became as a nom de band for American folk singer Justin Vernon and he released his first album 'For Emma, Forever Ago' to good critical reaction last year. This new single sees Bon Iver become an actual group for the very first time with Mike Noyce and Sean Carey now confirmed as full time members of the outfit. 'Blood Bank' a wonderfully relaxing single awash with lush harmonies and well worth five minutes of your time if you haven't already had a chance to hear it.

The very fact that this is the last of only three new entries to the Top 40 this week throws into sharp relief the debate that was sparked in many place online about just how "interesting" the singles chart had become now that the number of songs passing through it has dropped dramatically thanks to the tendancy of big hits to sell in steady quantities over a much longer period of time. I can remember ten years ago being flooded with emails and queries from peope questioning the validity of the singles chart when it was sufferering from breathtaking levels of turnover, with around 15 new entries every week being considered normal. "How much better it was," they would complain "when singles climbed the chart slowly and hits were allowed to develop, it is just rubbish these days". Fast forward to the present day and the grumbles can now be heard from those used to such a rollercoaster ride, complaining that a chart that moves gracefully and steadily just does not hold any interest for them. If I'm still around when the pendulum swings back again, I'll make sure to dig out this piece as an example of how nobody is ever truly satisfied.

66 Comments

1. Steve -
Great review as usual James. I like the progress of Jason Mraz, week by week, a few places at a time. Why have Weezer crept back in?

Where you state 3 new entries, you don't count ones which have come in from outside the top 75. What is the cannonical reference here? Many would always go to the Guiness Book of British Hit singles. This would give us quite a few more (EG Shontelle, Fleet Foxes).

Steve Kidd

2. Matthew -
Interesting to see Lady Ga Ga selling yet another 70,000 copies. Her song is very infectious and can understand all the hype around this song, predict very big things for this girl! Glad to see the dreary 'Loving Kind' taking a desend down the charts. This shouldn't have entered the top 10 at all.

3. ROBERT -
what happened to the girls aloud album that was at number 10 last week?

4. Yahoo! Music User -
Good to hear that White Lies are number one in the album chart. I was surprised that the single wasn't higher when I looked earlier but I'm sure a number one album isn't going to be too disappointing for them :)

5. Stewart -
the last paragraph is so true..you can't please all the people all the time. i generally prefer a slower moving chart so long as it doesn't become to the pace that the American hot 100 is at.i'm really hoping Annie Lennox's new single 'shining light' will get her back in the top 40 (at least) and lady gaga's 'poker face' is top 10 bound for sure.

6. brett -
It seems that The Script's 'Breakeven' is destined to be a high selling but low peaking hit. Its 12 week chart runs is as follows: 34-24-25-25-27-28-31-26-21-23-24-33. Although still hanging on at number 33 it seems unlikely that it will ever hit the top 20.

Please join my facebook group UK TOP 40 CHART CHAT

7. Yahoo! Music User -
Why is Poker Face charting at the same time as Just Dance a problem? Look at Beyoncé, Single Ladies charted just shortly after If I Were A Boy & it hasn't harmed its chances of becoming a top 10 hit. Lady GaGa is currently at #5 in Ireland with Poker Face and at #1 with Just Dance.

Great to see the Alesha Dixon follow up doing so well, especially ahead of release. Glad she has managed to pull off the crucial follow up single. So many acts fail to do so these days. Rock on Alesha!! Delighted that Jason Mraz is continuing to climb now up to #22. Would love to see it go top 10 in the coming weeks. It'll make up for the disastrous situation in which Bubbly by Colbie Caillat flopped twice . . .

Loving the Fray's new single. Disappointing to see it lingering at #46 though. Hope it improves greatly next week.

Finally I see Rihanna has fallen to #38 this week. If Rehab falls out of the top 40 next week, will this be like the first time in 6 thousand years that Rihanna hasn't got a single in the top 40?

8. brett -
On the subject of slow climbing etc, I'm 26 and listened to the charts from a very young age, Back in the late 90s and early 00s I was so frustrated by the way the charts had gone, I could vaguely remember the days of the climbers and was so shocked when Whigfield's Saturday night suddenly entered at number 1 (the first artist to spend her first ever week in the chart at number 1 - with the exception of the very first chart in 1952 - Al Martino? I could be wrong). For me Whigfield's debut at the top was the begining of the end for interesting charts and climbing, to me the current chart climate is a golden age.

9. John -
someone asked how do you consider if an artist is a one-hit wonder, and generally its when their biggest single goes top 10 and their next best offering misses the top 40. But really, each and every case is different.
Say if a song debuts at #10 then is gone from the top 75 2 or 3 weeks later can you call it a hit? and there are a few songs that just miss top 40 but can spend quite a few months in the top 75.

Good to see pink making inroads, not her best song, its actually one of her worst in the past few years, but thats coz most of her songs are so good.
The songs already made its impact in australia and now her 3rd single 'please dont leave me' is making inroads.

10. Stephen N -
Back in the days of dotmusic, there used to be other countries' charts here apart from UK singles & albums...lots of people refer in their posts to the success songs are having in other regions...it would be good to see the US charts, maybe the Ireland, Australia charts here too...
And there was a running total chart of the year too, so as the year went by you could see if Lady Gaga was the phenomenon her chart position implied, or was just the beneficiary of a slow month...

11. Yahoo! Music User -
I tell you a bad thing about downloads! It has done away with the Local sales charts that used to be on Radio stations. Now you can't tell what is selling in Scotland or Leeds or just London.
How come Bon Ivor are in the top 40. I have looked around the sales charts and not one has it selling a bean! Even Sunday's I-Tunes!
FIDDLE springs to mind!!!
The term "one hit wonder" has been corupted over the years. It should refer to an artist who has 1 Number One Hit and then nothing else in the chart again. The first being Kitty Kallen. The latest will be the X-factor Finalists, since the chances are pretty remote of them recording another song.

12. CJ -
I also prefer the charts like this, it was ridiculous back in the 90's when you knew that a song would go into the charts at number 1 and not be there next week, anyone remember in 2000 when there was 12 new number one singles in 12 weeks, that was stupid, thats how the likes of drivel bands like Westlife managed to get so many number ones. I'm still waiting for the next time when every single song spends more than a week at number one, last time was back in 1992.

Singles are selling more nowadays and it looks like albums are on their way out.

13. Robin T -
I agree with post seven that there's no problem with Poker Face being in the charts as well as Just Dance

The same thing happened with Britney Spears (Circus) and Kings of Leon (Use Somebody) and also The Ting Tings, and they all hung around for a few weeks, dropped out of the chart and still had big hits afterwards - Kings of Leon getting as high as number two.

14. brett -
LOL @ No 7 'Finally I see Rihanna has fallen to #38 this week. If Rehab falls out of the top 40 next week, will this be like the first time in 6 thousand years that Rihanna hasn't got a single in the top 40?'

Sorry to dissapoint but don't forget that Rihanna is also at number 25 with 'Live your life', I can't see that leaving the chart for at least 2 or 3 weeks.

15. Sean -
This probably isn't the right forum to be saying it, but I think this week's Top 10 Albums Chart is a corker. It has everything. New entries and climbers. Rock, pop, dance, r'n'b, indie. Bands, vocal groups, female and male soloists. Established stars, successful debuts and breakthrough material. Brits, Yanks and Irish acts. No Greatest Hits. No reality tv stars. I own 4 of the Top 10, but all of the other 6 interest me, and I will be checking each of them out in the coming weeks. It's a classic week.

16. Sam -
in response to post #1, weezer are back in with beverley hills due to the use for advertising for the new series of 90210 on e4

17. Yahoo! Music User -
I love Lady GaGa she is the best and all my friends enjoy her music. But i never would have gussed her top of the charts.

18. Yahoo! Music User -
With regards to the one hit wonder arguments.
Back in 1974, Terry Jacks was regarded as a one hit wonder, with the number 1 hit, Seasons in the sun, and this has appeared on quite a few one hit wonder compilation cds, but his follow up was If you go away, which was also a top 10 hit, reaching number 8.
Confused?.
So am i.

19. Yahoo! Music User -
too much to read!!!

20. Rich -
I prefer the purist one-hit-wonder of one number 1 and nothing else (not even a colaboration) with the one offs of Elton and Kiki and the X-Factor Finalists being in a separate group. If you don't separate those out then practically every R&B number one is a one hit wonder as most collabarations (Eminem & Dido etc.) don't happen again.

I was all ready to knock Gaga for a multi week number one single selling less than 100k lifetime, but I'm plesantly surprised to see the actual figures here.

All speeds of chart interest me, and as james says at some point it's bound to go lightning fast again (especially if the proposed no albums just groups of tracks things really takes off).
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Take That Eurovision!

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 10:42AM GMT

Dotmusic - Gary Barlow to write 2010 theme tune? More »

More News Stories