Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending February 28th 2009

Posted Sun 22 Feb 2009 10:11PM GMT by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

They call it the "Brits effect" - the otherwise unexplained surge in sales for acts whose music featured or who waltzed off with the prizes at the British record industry's annual award ceremony. Most years there are one or two noteworthy leaps in support for the acts which have benefitted from some useful prime time TV exposure, but I can't quite remember a year like this one in which just about every big chart story of the week has some kind of Brits connection.

Let's deal with album sales first of all, which is where most the effect is felt. Sure enough double award winners Kings Of Leon charge back to Number One with 'Only By The Night', followed hard on the heels of Best British Album 'Rockferry' by Duffy which races back to Number 4, only denied a Top 3 place by the expected strong arrival of Morrissey's 'Years Of Refusal' which arrives at Number 3. 'Seldom Seen Kid' by Best British Group winners Elbow charges 23-5, 'We Started Nothing' by the Ting Tings (who didn't win anything but still got to perform) charges 33-8 and there are also strong placings for Seasick Steve (Number 9) and Coldplay (Number 15) with a widely expected chart return for the Pet Shop Boys' hits collection 'Pop Art' which re-charts at Number 19 following their medley performance in the wake of their Outstanding Contribution award. So far, so in line with expectations.

It is on the ever moveable singles chart however that the run really starts. Leading the charge in extraordinary fashion are Kings Of Leon whose Brits performance moves 'Use Somebody' to a 12-3 leap, returning the single to the Top 3 a full 10 weeks after it first peaked at Number 2. Former Number One 'Sex On Fire' also rebounds, moving 19-14 for its highest position for five weeks.

The two leading contenders for Best British Single both return to the Top 40. They may have been pipped at the post, but Coldplay surge 45-27 with 'Viva La Vida' whilst eventual winner 'The Promise' by Girls Aloud returns to the Top 40 after five weeks away at Number 39. Both older singles advance at the expense of what are theoretically the "current" singles for both acts. Coldplay's 'Life In Technicolor 2' collapses to Number 74 whilst 'The Loving Kind' by Girls Aloud (ironically penned by the Outstanding Contributions awardees) drops to Number 43.

Also making at Top 40 return is 'One Day Like This' by Elbow. First released in June last year, the single has so far spent 15 weeks on the Top 75 in a variety of sporadic runs, reappearing every so often after the tune is used either on a TV soundtrack or as a heavily featured part of the advertising for the 'Seldom Seen Kid' album. This week's surge marks its fourth appearance inside the Top 40 and for the moment matches the peak it scaled second time around in late July last year. The closest this most fondly regarded of British acts have ever come to a mainstream hit single is a trio of Number 19 hits, and it would be nice to think that one consequence of their Brit recognition would be a proper chart run for their most acclaimed single to date.

Lower down there is an expected surge for the Ting Tings who reappear at Number 58 with 'That's Not My Name' whilst Queen of the evening Duffy sees her two most famous singles also stage a chart comeback. 'Warwick Avenue' is at Number 71 with 'Mercy' making even greater strides at Number 60 - exactly a year since it was locked firmly at the top of the chart. Having run through some of their greatest hits (with the odd underdressed guest star), the Pet Shop Boys also have a sprinkling of tracks dotted around the muddier end of the chart. Leading the charge are 1986 Number One 'West End Girls' at Number 90 and the 1987 Christmas Number One 'Always On My Mind' at Number 97.

Returning to more contemporary matters, it almost seems a chart footnote to acknowledge the continuing run of 'The Fear' by Lily Allen at Number One, there now for a fourth straight week. There is similarly no move for the record she replaced, 'Just Dance' by Tennant and Lowe's new best friend Lady Gaga which remains locked at Number 2, even if she did have to fight off a challenge from the aforementioned 'Use Somebody'. Meanwhile her second chart single of the moment 'Poker Face' continues to make good progress and moves 22-15 in a move that suggests she could well have two Top 10 hits in fairly short order.

A busy Top 10 sees a pleasing four place rise for 'Omen' by the Prodigy, this now enough to make the single their highest charting release since their back to back Number One singles 'Firestarter' and 'Breathe' way back in 1996. Shontelle moves 10-6 with 'T-Shirt' whilst there is a five place rise for 'Whatcha Think About That' which returns both the Pussycat Dolls and Missy Elliott to the Top 10 at Number 10. Previous single 'I Hate This Part' broke the Dolls' career-opening streak of Top 10 singles when it peaked at Number 12 back in January whilst Missy Elliott hasn't featured on a track that has ventured this high since her own 'Lose Control' hit Number 7 in the summer of 2005.

Take a deep breath because the chart stories don't end there. In one of the more shocking developments of the week, U2 can only manage what is for them an unusually low Number 12 entry for new single 'Get On Your Boots', this despite the band featuring as part of the Brits ceremony in the week. Taken from forthcoming new album 'No Line On The Horizon', the new single has suffered rather from a lack of online interest which has meant it has been reliant on the its limited number of physical sales to chart. Not since the very start of their career has a brand new U2 single failed to reach the Top 10, and although it has only missed by a whisker and it would be wrong to write it off just yet, there is a good chance that 'Get On Your Boots' could become their first "proper" release to miss the Top 10 since 'If God Will Send His Angels' similarly limped to Number 12 in December 1997. Let's keep things in perspective here - given that they are just shy of 30 years of recording together, the fact that they can even have a Number 12 hit with consummate ease is something at which to marvel.

After underperforming slightly with a Number 44 entry last week, some hefty promotional work has paid off for Miley Cyrus who shoots to Number 16 with 'Fly On The Wall'. That is a big improvement on the Number 25 peak of her last single '7 Things' and bodes well for her chances of beating debut single 'See You Again' which made Number 11 last September.

One place behind at Number 17 is 'Dead And Gone' from TI and Justin Timberlake which makes a 13 place climb this week having been on the rise for the best part of the last month. Effectively this single is a favour returned after the rapper played the guest starring role on Trousersnake's own 'My Love' which hit Number 2 at the tail end of 2006. Just to prove that eventually all R&B stars end up appearing on each other's records, Justin Timberlake's last chart appearance was as a guest star on Rihanna's 'Rehab' whilst T.I. himself was last seen on his own Number 2 hit 'Live Your Life' alongside a certain Bajan guest star whose name I'm sure I don't have to spell out.

The parade of new hits just keeps on coming as we hit the Top 30. New in at Number 22 is 'Love Story' from US country star Taylor Swift. Marketing C&W acts on these shores always requires a bit of creative thinking, so it is probably no surprise that the track chosen for her first ever UK release is the least "country" track from her second album 'Fearless'. Nonetheless promoting the untouched album track would still have been a step too far, hence what has charted here is the "International Radio Mix" which refreshingly retains the banjo plucking from the album version but which adds a bassline, drums and an electric guitar solo to properly Euro it up in true Shania Twain style. Whilst purists may bemoan this it does at least mean that 'Love Story' works perfectly as a breezy uplifting pop ballad that more than deserves to turn her into a star outside her own country. Consider this first chart placing a step in the right direction and watch it rocket next week.

Those who prefer their music a little meatier may prefer 'Everybody' from Rudenko which arrives at Number 24. The Bassline club track runs the risk of being a little formulaic, right down to its scantily clad booty-shaking video which I include below for research purposes only of course, but lead singer Charlene Reena works hard to inject the single with just the right level of sensuality.

Don't like that? Then go for the track one place below as Gary Go arrives at Number 25 with his debut hit 'Wonderful'. The singer-songwriter is being acclaimed as pop's next big thing with a lucrative support slot with Take That lined up for the summer. With an image that is best described as a cross between Buddy Holly and Brad from Rocky Horror, he is a most unlikely looking pop star, but if the rest of his material is half as appealing as his debut hit then all the hype could well be justified.

Meanwhile there is more bright and breezy guitar pop at Number 31 as Honey Ryder arrive on the chart with 'Fly Away'. You may remember they are the pair who are aiming to go it alone as far as possible, funding their recordings by selling shares in their future profits and marketing themselves to investors as a business startup. Their first single 'Numb' crept to Number 32 last August, since when they have toured with Will Young and performed at a variety of industry showcases. My lavish praise for the first hit is one of many superlatives from reviewers that garlands their MySpace page, so I feel almost honour bound to give them a new quote. Take it from me that 'Fly Away' is the kind of effortless radio-friendly pop that was supposed to have either being uninvented or fallen out of fashion long ago. It is my favourite kind of music - the sort that makes you feel good about liking it and even happier to be alive to hear it.

Finally(!) for this week, something I spent time on the podcast last week boldly predicting didn't actually come to pass. There did exist the possibility that a prime time TV would make a small chart invasion, thanks to a head to head challenge on Ant and Dec's Saturday Night Takeaway for the presenters to each record their own charity single and release them midweek. As viewers to the show will have learned on Saturday night, Team Dec were the winners, selling more copies of their rendition of 'Wake Me Up Before You Go Go' than Team Ant who were some distance behind with their cover of 'Don't Stop Moving'. Despite copious press coverage of the stunt and some hard promotional work by the pair (including a visit to my office during the week which saw the tallest member of the team provoke barely suppressed mirth by crouching on the floor for a photo opportunity) none of this actually translated into significant sales. Maybe the fact that the singles were only available at 7Digital via a link on the ITV website, or maybe just that both records are a bit rubbish was to blame, but on the official chart this week Team Dec languish at Number 64 and Team Ant at a mere Number 79. Ah well.

59 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
I thought "I Hate This Part" peaked at #12, not #15...

2. joel -
Great commentary James and an interesting chart this week. Just a little correction: PCD's "I Hate This Part" reached no.12.

I'm shocked at how well Kings of Leon have done based on their Brit Awards performance, but I'm even more gobsmacked (and a little gutted), that U2 can't reach the Top 10 with their new single. It's so odd for their first single off a new albuum to chart that low...

Can anyone tell me what that website is that shows the Top 100 history of any single or album? Many thanks!

3. Yahoo! Music User -
The low chart position of the U2 single is quite remarkable. With the exception of 'Stay' (the only single taken from 'Zooropa') every first single from a new U2 album (not counting compilations) has made number one since 1988 (when 'Desire' became their first number one). This is remarkable consistency, so to see a brand new U2 single miss the top ten on week of release is nothing short of shocking. Indeed, their last album even contained two number one singles.

This seems to confirm a real trend: guitar bands are struggling to sell singles, as fans of the six-stringed instrument increasingly prefer to buy albums alone. It's interesting that Kings Of Leon are the only band who are bucking this trend, which I find curious as their songs do not strike me as being particularly strong or commercial.

4. Bob7071 -
Morrissey at number 3 without Brits support! The British public does have some taste afterall.

5. Iain -
James, perhaps you were thinking of Sara Bareilles when you referred to Taylor Swift's track as 'Love Song'?

Good to see the singles chart get a bit of a shake up this week. I wonder if it will be Taylor Swift or Kelly Clarkson who will knock Lily from number 1 next week?

6. Yahoo! Music User -
The Brit effects didn't seem to make as much of an impact as i thought.
Kings of Leon climb back to 3, but apart from that, no really big climbers in the top 40.
Even Duffy can only manage number 60 this week with Mercy, and Paul Weller winning best male hasn't done his sales any good.
He doesn't even feature in the top 75 singles or album chart this week.
I couldn't have been more wrong with my predicition last week, that The Prodigy would probably drop out of the top 40 this week, and it has climbed an impressive 4 places to 4 this week, with only Morrissey doing his usual trick and dropping down like a stone.
Great to finally see Taylor Swift make the top 40, but i do prefer her earlier stuff, as it was more country then, and she seems to be doing what other great country stars have done, and gone more mainstream, so she can appeal to a bigger audience, which seems to work for her.

7. Padraig S -
Great to see the Prodigy in the Top 5 again. And Elbow's One Day Like This surely deserves a proper chart run even if most of us have heard it by now. Have Take That's new single completely flopped? U2's non top 10 appearance is a shocker, is it due to leaks of the album?

8. James -
gooner194 - I shall join you in the "wrong" corner with regards to Prodigy, and second your comments re: Taylor Swift... several tracks from her first album seemed ever-present in the states last year, and fully crossed over into the US pop mainstream, which is a lot more friendly to country music than ours. I haven't grown to love "Love Story" yet - will pick up the album this week, because I have a feeling I'll enjoy the full-country version more.

Two questions I'd do the research myself to answer if I wasn't at work:-

When was the last time the top two positions were unchanged for four consecutive weeks? Does it date back to Wet Wet Wet / All-4-One in '95, or has it happened more recently?

Kings of Leon is inside the Top 3, after what I reckon is 20 weeks inside the Top 40 - when did this last happen? ("Rockstar" left the Top 3 after 18 weeks).

Have a good week!

9. James -
Oops... to correct myself, WWW & All-4-One was 1994.

10. Pete -
In answer to Imanni B's posting (no.83 last week) Saint Etienne HAVE physically released 'Method of Modern Love' as a limited run of 1500 of each of the 2 CD formats & the 7inch. You may still be able to get these (signed) formats through Lovers Unite - their fanclub, or Recordstore on line. I do the vinly rounds in Londons fashionable West End every Monday and didn't see them in the shop(s) at all. Do check out the Cola Boy remix if you can. Anyway, the fact that this was a limited run was probably a contributing factor to there disappointing no56 position. It is frustrating when the song has HIT written all over it but part of the charm of the band is the understated way they seem forever to stay just out of the spotlight. Plus with currently no TOTP, there is nowhere for Sarah to wave her feather boa anymore so no motivation there!

Re. Kings of Leon. Hmmm, Just why are they succeding where other guitar bands are not?? Might this have something to do with the fact they are b***y beautiful boys??

11. Yahoo! Music User -
What amazed me this week is that Duffy landed at 71. However what staggers me beyond belief because it is totally wrong is Leona's Run at 38! Here's why: (and by the way it's based on facts) Amazon 15, 7Digital 16, Play 18, HMV 10, the only place it's low is no I-tunes and that's 44! It's been like that for weeks too!
As for I-tunes comment by another blogger ruling the roost, well the fact it's number one (Kings of Leon) isn't the top blows that argument out of the water (though I'm not saying it doesn't's have massive effect). Where should it be then? 15 up from 18 is the answer.

Aside from that what the charts do show this week is that the public needs a TV show to cater for chart music on the main channels. And till we get a weekly show, the telly people are thus failing in the service to provide for a large section of the public.

12. steve -
Is it just me or the new Saint Etienne single does indeed have more in common than a passing resemblance with Kylie's "The One"? And why is that this new single doesn't appear on the best of compilation it is supposed to promote? Is it a new kind of marketing strategy I'm just not yet aware of? :-)))

13. Yahoo! Music User -
Is no-one going to state the obvious reason why the U2 single has flopped? It's rubbish. And I say that as a U2 fan since 1991. In my opinion, it's a tuneless mess and its poor sales seem to suggest I'm not alone in thinking that.

And I think someone should write a thesis on why Kings of Leon seem to be the only guitar/indie/rock band selling consistently in the mainstream. Their album and the two hit singles are very good, but not exceptional in my opinion. I have no idea why they've been adopted by kids and the mainstream where other often better bands and songs have been completely ignored. I assume there are "non-music" reasons involved, but I don't understand it.

14. Pete -
Love the comment about U2- well said!

Kings of Leon are extremely hot. End of Thesis.

Saint Etienne had a problem with their production of the CD's end of last year-'London Converstion' was due to be released in Ocober with 'This Is Tomorrow' being the second new single to be taken from it to promote it. So having time on their hands they got together with Richard X & did "Method of missing the top 50 altogether" and added this as a double A-side to 'This is Tomorrow' but this was too late to be included on most pressings- and only features on the lovely DVD pack. It's typical of a band who have been dogged by record company/distribution problems but continue on in their own eccentric way.

Re. it sounding like Kylie's The One, it was very pleasing to hear that Girls Aloud won a Brit for the top single 'The Promise', but shocked that a cover song was allowed to win this prestigious award! Will the producers of BBC1's Blankety Blank now be suing for Royalties??
Maybe they should write a blankety blank cheque out to Les Dawson's widow?

15. Gordon -
I have to agree with reason to the poor chart performance of U2, this single is quite frankly shocking.
In the past they have given us such wonderful music, and if they think this mess will once again grant them 'Best Band In The World' status they are sadly mistaken.

I expect a high new entry from Kelly Clarkson next week, after breaking chart records in the US already and high new entries all over the world it shows a great return to form.

My future tip for a chart smash has to be Freemasons ft Sophie Ellis Bextor - Heartbreak Make Me A Dancer, just confirmed as there next single, watch it FLY !!

16. steve -
Thanks to pete.jdixon for his explanation, it's greatly appreaciated!

17. Yahoo! Music User -
It's great to see the PCD's back in the top 10 after missing it with ironically my fave PCD single to date I Hate This Part. It's nice to see that other singles aren't following this trend. Going physical this week maybe they can go even higher. It will be interesting to see if Shontelle's T-Shirt can crack the top 3 this week too, seeming it has also been released.

Why do people think Taylor Swift's Love Story will storm the charts next week? I thought ut's not out till Mar 2nd? Would love to see Kelly Clarkson score her first UK #1 single, sadly I don't think it will happen. Her highest charting singlr to date is a #5 position. Maybe she can improve on that at least. Loving the Sats new single, is it a guaranteed #1 since it's the Comic Relief single? They def deserved a Brit nomination for Best Breakthrough Act I thought. Obviously the Brits academy though otherwise. The snubbing of the Script & Leona Lewis was absolutely scandalous.

Great to see Elbow back in the top 40 with A Day Like This. . . Great track. Although I don't think they deserved the Best Group nod! Shocked at Coldplay's tumble to #74 with the amazing Life in Technicolour 2. It's my fave Coldplay single since Yellow. As others said last week & James this week surely it would have made more sense to perform newer singles at the Brits? I would have thought Coldplay would perform Life in Technicolour, Kings of Leon Revelry, GA Loving Kind. Surely it would have made more sense.

And on the U2 debate. Yes it's a poor offering but the other thing is that this is their first single in the digital download era. Maybe in the past their fans were loyal physical CD buyers and everyone is just waiting for the album. Or maybe they have just spent too much time out of the spotlight. Look what happened Dido last year . . . Comeback single & album totally bombed. And she was as big as Duffy is today in her heyday. Also a number of long running established artists are struggling in the download era, U2 obviously, Madonna (Miles Away casualty) Kylie (The One) Coldplay (Lost) Britney (Break the Ice/Circus) Christina Aguilera (Keeps Gettin Better) to name but a few. Disappointed Circus failed to crack the top 10. One of Britney's best tracks . . . In fact her last 5 singles are perhaps amongst the best of her career . . Piece of Me & Womanizer in particular.

18. Yahoo! Music User -
I have been a big U2 fan, ever since they had their first big hit in 1980 with New Years Day, and i have liked all their hit singles, although Vertigo took a while for me to like, but i can't get my head round their new one, and the only thing i like about it, is The Edge thrashing it out on the guitar.
One thing that is almost 100% guaranteed, is that the album should go to number 1, and the single, assuming it's out as a physical release, will probably drop to around 32, but then again, after my disastrous prediction last week, that the Prodigy will drop out of the top 40 this week, i will probably be totally wrong.
I don't expect Elbow to stay a 2nd week in the chart though.

19. Yahoo! Music User -
Have to agree with the last part of post 19 about U2. The Ipod market is for the young at the moment, as the older rock generation don't like things that look like hearing aids around the heads! It's nothing to do with the quality of the songs, as the CD went in at one on HMV chart.
But on the other acts mentioned by 19, it's down to crap marketing and the music industry itself not knowing how to flog downloads properly.

20. Yahoo! Music User -
Post 10,
i'm not sure whether the last time the top 2 were the same for more than 4 weeks, but certainly in 1994, the number 1 song was Love is all around, by Wet Wet Wet, and number 2 was I swear, by Boys 2 Men, and they were both at the number 1 & 2 spot for 7 weeks, although The Wets were number 1 for 15 weeks.
Back in 1991, Bryan Adams and Right said Fred, held the number 1 and 2 spot for 6 weeks, with Bryan Adams, spending a record 16 weeks at the top.
I'm not sure of any others that have spent longer together at 1 & 2 respectively, and i'm not going to waste a whole evening, trying to get info.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jay-Z for BRITs

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 11:12AM GMT

Dotmusic - Rap don to perform medley at London bash More »

More News Stories