Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending March 28th 2009

Posted Sun 22 Mar 2009 9:04PM GMT by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

As I hinted at the end of the podcast last week, the chart makes up for a lack of big new hit singles by treating us to one of the most tense battles for Number One for some considerable time. Although there was a small chance that the Comic Relief single 'Islands In The Stream' would retain its crown, early sales flashes indicated that the record it deposed from the top - 'Right Round' by Flo Rida - was also a strong contender, the gap between the two singles as little as 300 copies at one point early in the week. By Friday 'Islands In The Stream' was fading fast and it seemed as if Flo Rida was on course to become the first artist in almost three years to regain the Number One position after losing it.

Instead he fails, a late surge at the weekend instead puts 'Poker Face' by Lady Gaga at the summit of the official singles chart by the small margin of some 221 sales. Having first appeared to peak at Number 3 three weeks ago, the single suffered from the size of the market and the presence of several big selling singles, increasing its sales week by week yet actually slipping down the chart as records above overtook it. Indeed when last week the track fell to Number 4 it set a new benchmark for the highest sale for that chart position in over five years. Indeed sales of 'Poker Face' actually slip ever so slightly this week, the single selling 53,699 copies compared to 55,293 a week ago.

Nonetheless a Number One single it is at last, giving Lady Gaga her second chart-topper in the space of two and a half months - its predecessor 'Just Dance' still also selling well and shifting in its seat slightly to rest at Number 12 this week. Whilst it may not be directly linked to a 1980s hit unlike the two previous incumbents of the Number One position, the bouncy electropop of 'Poker Face' means it is as 80s retro as it gets, a production that would not sound a day out of place had it been released in 1981. Indeed such is the vibe of the 2009 music scene at present that 'Poker Face' is actually an appropriate talisman for some of the weeks other new releases, not to mention the three singles below which once again either cover or sample hits of the 80s.

More on that in a moment, first we must acknowledge the passing of 'Islands In The Stream' which slumps to an unexpected Number 3, keeping pace still with its Comic Relief twin 'Just Can't Get Enough' by The Saturdays which rests at Number 4. As one eagle-eyed commenter last week pointed out, by topping the charts last week the single ensured that a song written by the Bee Gees has been Number One in each of the last five decades. It is a quite sensational feat, one that is unmatched by any other song-writing partnership. The most obvious other contenders for the honour are naturally one or both of Lennon and McCartney, but whilst we had Beatles-penned tracks have been Number One in the 60s, 80s and 2000s, Paul McCartney songs at the top in the 70s and 80s and John Lennon compositions at the summit in the 80s, a lack of Number One hits composed by either man in the 90s means they fall just short of the song-writing consistency shown by the Brothers Gibb. The only other songwriters with a similar record are the various members of Queen, whose songs have been at Number One in the 70s, 80s, 90s and 2000s although a case can be made for Andersson and Ulvaeus of Abba who also penned songs which made Number One in the 70s, 80s and 90s and received a songwriting credit on Madonna's 'Hung Up' in 2005. The latter hit sampled their own 'Gimme Gimme Gimme (A Man After Midnight)' so technically they didn't actually directly write the song, but if we are going on purely songwriting credits then for completeness sake we have to acknowledge it.

Just one single climbs into the Top 10 this week, 'Halo' by Beyonce continuing its upward trajectory with a 20-9 rise. It further ensures her consistent record of Top 10 hits, being her 13th as a credited solo artist. With 'Listen' having shoulder-barged its way to a Top 10 placing just before Christmas, her only singles outside of Destiny's Child to miss the Top 10 are now 2004's 'Me Myself and I' (Number 11) and 2007 release 'Green Light' (Number 12).

Back in time then to the 1980s, for just like 'Poker Face' the single that enters at Number 11 is infused throughout by the spirit of the neon-soaked decade. Electropop duo La Roux consist of producer Ben Langmaid and frontwoman Elly Jackson, the duo having been tipped for great things following the release of their debut single 'Quicksand' on a small independent label at the back end of last year. Having been snapped up by a major label, 'In For The Kill' effortlessly becomes their first chart hit single. I'd share it with you to let you judge its merits for yourself, but for idiotic "this video is not available in your country" messages on YouTube. A shame really, some of the people reading this might have liked it enough to buy a copy for themselves, what a wasted opportunity.

Appropriately enough the next single is not so much inspired by the 1980s, but performed by one of the acts whose work from that decade informs and influences the production of both the Lady Gaga and La Roux singles. Fresh from their "outstanding contribution" gongs at last months Brit awards, the Pet Shop Boys arrive at Number 14 with brand new single 'Love Etc.', their highest charting single for three years and a release which means they can boast a hitmaking career spanning an impressive 23 years.

Now assessing any new work by Tennant and Lowe in chart terms is actually something of a minefield, for had a certain other set of 80s veterans not set the standard a few years earlier, our benchmark for chart uselessness might well have been called "Pet Shop Boys Syndrome". Here's the problem: it doesn't matter how much work they put into their new album, how much press they do to promote it or how well received it is critically. This new single and new album 'Yes' (released this week) will sell to absolutely nobody outside their long-term hard core of fans. This blunt statement isn't just based on the perfunctory in and out performance of just about every single they have released in the last ten years, but the utterly dismal sales performance of their albums. Of all the records they have released since 1999, Greatest Hits collection 'Pop Art' is the only one that can boast a shelf life beyond a month.

Just check out the stats. 1999's 'Nightlife' spent two weeks on the album chart, 2002's 'Release' just one. Their 2006 offering 'Fundamental' may have been hailed as an impressive return to form when first released but it too just had a four week chart run before vanishing forever. It saddens me to see it, as the Pet Shop Boys were my favourite group growing up and I avidly collected every single one of their releases during the 80s and 90s. I don't point this out from the position of someone who dislikes their music but the sad truth is that the cultural and creative contribution of their music these days is almost precisely zero. 'Love Etc.' may well be one of the most fun, pop-focused and commercially appealing records they have made in a long time, but I can almost guarantee that you won't find it on the Top 75 within a fortnight and whilst 'Yes' may well have a Top 10 debut on the album chart next week, you won't find it in the shops by Easter. That my friends is Depeche Mode syndrome, and you have to wonder why they continue to bother.

It's been seven years since the winner of the Oscar for Best Original Song has been a chart hit of any note, but that changes this week with the arrival of 'Jai Ho (You Are My Destiny)' at Number 20. The centrepiece of the soundtrack of "Slumdog Millionaire', the song was written by A.R. Rahman and on the soundtrack of the film is performed by Sukhwinder Singh, Tanvi Shah, Mahalakshmi Iyer and Vijay Prakash. For this new commercial version, the vocals are performed by the Pussycat Dolls in what is being promoted as a new interpretation of the original. Credited to the composer himself with the girls relegated to guest stars, the track will feature on 'Doll Domination 2.0', a re-released version of their second album (which first came out last year) which features a mixture of new songs and a handful of tracks from the original. With their last single 'Whatcha Think About That' having been a Top 10 hit just two weeks ago (and still on the Top 40 at Number 26) this is the speedy follow-up to end all others, but as a world away from the R&B sludge of some of their other releases it is an inspired and uplifting breath of fresh air. You may have to take my word for it, as "this video is not available in your country" (although it is on Spotify if you look hard enough) but I'd love to think this has "future Number One" written all over it.

Charging their way into the Top 40 after first entering just outside last week is 'No You Girls' by Franz Ferdinand which lands at Number 27. The follow-up to 'Ulysses' which made Number 20 back in January, the single is yet another example of the band possibly milking the formula further than necessary. As jaunty, bouncy and catchy as everything they have ever released, the overwhelming feeling that we heard it all five years ago is hard to escape.

He may have blown hot and cold at times, but there is no doubting the impressive consistency of Enrique Iglesias who this years marks ten years as a chart star. His current Greatest Hits collection marks this decade of hits and obligatory new track 'Takin' Back My Love' grabs itself a Top 40 place at Number 30 this week. The single features a guest vocal from Ciara, making him no less than the sixth different artist with which she has had a chart duet. Both artists have Number One hits to their name, Ciara having hit the top with her debut single 'Goodies' in January 2005 whilst Enrique Iglesias had his own moment of glory three years earlier when 'Hero' replicated its worldwide success and topped the UK charts. Whilst he has spent most of his career trying to downplay his family connections and has a notoriously distant relationship with his superstar father, I can't be the only person hoping that one day we get to hear a Julio/Enrique duet on record. Done correctly, it surely has the potential to be massive.

76 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
Great to see La Roux's single charting so high. It's as stylish a single as has been released this year. As someone who grew up in the 80s, I can only applaud at how thoroughly the duo has followed through with the retro theme. Not only do Ellie's hairstyle (inspired by A Flock Of Seagulls?) the Night Rider-themed video recall the decade of pop excess, but the single's even available as a shaped vinyl picture disc. There haven't been many of those released recently...

And, with Lady Gaga at number one, and The Pet Shop Boys back, I feel like I've gone to sleep and woken up in 1986!

2. yentlbreakdown -
I agree about the Pet Shop Boys commercially, but creatively?

Would Madonna/Girls Aloud etc work with them if they were creatively redundant?

3. joel -
I must say I'm pretty happy Lady Gaga's "Poker Face" has climbed to no.1. It's a catchy song which I believe's better that "Just Dance". James - great commentary, but careful about what you're saying re how many singles she sold. I'm sure "you-know-who" will say she's 3rd with 44,000 copies behind Leona (47,000), and September (44,500)!! It's a conspiracy I tell ya!

Akon's climbed again. Can anyone shed some light re any record he may be close to breaking/have equalled/have broken?

When's Nelly Furtado releasing new material? I love her stuff and what with "Broken Strings" still selling well, maybe she could release a decent album on the back of this?

Is September releasing a new album in the UK with the UK version of "Can't Get Over" as well as other new tunes? I love all this eurodance stuff, but it's so limited over here in the UK.

4. Moe -
Awsome blog as usual James. Keep it up!

Ok everyone, the tracklisting for NOW 72 has been confirmed:

CD 1
Lily Allen - The Fear
Lady Gaga feat. Colby O'Donis - Just Dance
Flo Rida feat. Ke$ha - Right Round
Alesha Dixon - The Boy Does Nothing
The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough (Official Comic Relief Song)
Kelly Clarkson - My Life Would Suck Without You
Tinchy Stryder feat. Taio Cruz - Take Me Back
Kid Cudi vs Crookers - Day 'N' Nite
Britney Spears - Womanizer
T.I. feat. Rihanna - Live Your Life
Akon - Right Now (Na Na Na)
Shontelle - T-Shirt
Ne-Yo - Mad
The Saturdays - Issues
Leona Lewis - Forgive Me
Girls Aloud - The Loving Kind
September - Can't Get Over
Steve Angello & Laidback Luke Feat. Robin S - Show Me Love
N-Dubz - Strong Again
Katy Perry - Thinking Of You
Alexandra Burke - Hallelujah
X Factor Finalists 2008 - Hero

CD2
Take That - Greatest Day
Alesha Dixon - Breathe Slow
James Morrison & Nelly Furtado - Broken Strings
Taylor Swift - Love Story
P!nk - Sober
The Killers - Human
The Script - Breakeven
Jason Mraz - I'm Yours
Noisettes - Don't Upset The Rhythm (Go Baby Go)
Metro Station - Shake It
U2 - Get On Your Boots
MGMT - Kids
The Prodigy - Omen
Kevin Rudolf feat. Lil Wayne - Let It Rock
Wiley feat. Daniel Merriweather - Cash In My Pocket
Kanye West - Heartless
T.I. feat. Justin Timberlake - Dead & Gone
Daniel Merriweather feat. Wale - Change
Pet Shop Boys - Love Etc.
Duffy - Rain On Your Parade
Vanessa Jenkins, Bryn West & Sir Tom Jones feat. Robin Gibb - Islands In The Stream (For Comic Relief)

There you go, something to debate about for this week. My personal opinion: It could've been better, and I'm unsure as to why 3 different artists have 2 hits each in their own name(T.I., The Saturdays and Alesha Dixon) and why Beyonce has been skipped all together. Nonetheless still worth adding to my collection, and its good to see The Prodigy on the list!. Everyone else's opinion?

I love the Pet Shop Boys new single! So glad its in the Top 20!

Oasis is still in the Top 40 with "Falling Down" i wasn't expecting that at all. Neither was I expecting Poker face to reach #1 but it just goes to show that the charts aren't as predictable as some might make out. Sadly however, I still don't understand the hype surrounding her...

"No You Girls" should have been the lead single from the new Franz album. It reminds me very much of the likes of "Take Me Out" and "Do You Want To".

Take care everyone, and have an enjoyable week debating!

5. Yahoo! Music User -
post 3

I'm not so sure if he is close to breaking any records in the UK anytime soon, but I do know that Akon is one of few artists to have held #1 and #2 simultaneously on the Billboard Hot 100. I know T.I. is also one of them, and I know that back in the 1960s the Beatles at one point held the entire Top 5! Why, can you think of a record that Akon is close to breaking/has equalled/has broken in the UK?

So, it took 10 weeks for Poker Face to reach #1 on the UK Singles Chart in a single Top 40 spell. If it had got to #1 a few weeks later, it might have equaled or even beaten the 13 week record set by Celine Dion's "Think Twice". When was the last time it took a single 10 or more weeks to reach #1 in a single Top 40 spell? Or was it in fact the Celine Dion track in question? anyone know?

6. a1 -
hey nice to see the Gaga at top! like in OZ!
PSB are legends and if the young generation don't get it, well it's kinda expected!
still a new entry at 14 in today's digital world is fantastic!
re:"right round" i hope pete burns, S.A.W et al. get all the royalties for their epic masterpiece bieng disected by flo ho!

7. joel -
Post 5:

Akon's "Beautiful" has been in the chart for 13 non-consecutive weeks and I was wondering if it was the slowest climb to the no.8 position? Thanks for the Billboard trivia!

8. Robin T -
loz.etheridge, you are lucky to get Charlotte as well when interviewing Ash. The group split into two pairs when I did the interview and I got Mark instead!

I found Tim to be more desperate than any other band I've interviewed (Coldplay, Muse, Soulwax, Idlewild, Sneaker Pimps, Symposium, JJ72, Medal and the mighty Younger Younger 28's) for nothing bad to appear in print. I can understand as I read some press though - at the JD set he said that Thin Lizzy were the best Irish band, and this was deliberately written up as 'Ash slate U2' instead, which wasn't his intention at all.

The worst band I interviewed were Terris. Beliveing their own NME hype, they arrogantly thought they were going to be huge (Coldplay are supporting them, their tour manager said!) and didn't need to put any effort in to answering questions. They released one flop single and were never heard of again.

9. Robin T -
There were some comments last week about groups mis-spelling their hits or name, such as Soulja Boy, Swagga Like Us, Sk8er Boi etc

Were Slade the first band to do this (Coz I Luv You in 1971)... or can someone find an earlier example?

Perhaps there is some 50's or 60's hit in babytalk or slang?

10. Iain -
I agree James - I don't know why the Pet Shop Boys and Erasure bother releasing new material. Perhaps they are rewarding their loyal fan base? But I'm glad they do bother. Love Etc. is a great track. And who knows - Erasure may soon release a new album to the same standard as their thoroughly excellent 2005 release 'Nightbird'.

11. Milo -
Go GaGa!!!! Wishing for people to develop some taste and take the PSB into top ten territory (instead of buying rubbish like Flo Rida, what an embarrasing #1).

12. a1 -
oh well at least the Pet Shop Boys are #1 here
www.a1charts.blogspot.c o m

13. Yahoo! Music User -
3 different number 1's in 3 weeks.
I hope this isn't going to be what it was like 9 years ago, when we had a new number 1 almost every week.
I am glad that the 80.s style of music is making a come back, and i am looking forward to hearing the song by La Roux, although my local radio station doesn't play it, and it is not available on itunes apparently.
Oh well, if they (itunes)want to play silly beggars, then i shall have to download the song illegally, to try it out.

14. harisb -
One wonder what Beyonce or the number one song at the top contributes to the musical scene and culture other than pulling down it to new lows if PSB are doing nothing. What a nonsense piece of comment: Why do they bother? Throw DM (who sells stadium-full concerts) by the way...They bother because there are lots of fans out there and they love bothering but James, of course you have to go beyond silly figures (such such number this week and that that number that week) you don't even BOTHER to remember next week, and Jumas.,look at the things from a creative and artistic point of view if you can. Or just don't BOTHER writing silly comments about the music legends and listen to your number one songs like a 13-years-old cheerlady.

Sad to see that you were a fan...

15. Τυχερός -
Love etc. out of the Top 75 within a fortnight? I hope you are proven wrong James, It's a great track, the best they have done in ages, and it deserves a longer stay.

16. MIKE -
Happy to see Beyonce climbing!!!!!
Halo is her best song ever!!!

17. Döbler -
Love Love etc at 14... it´s a shame much better than all the previous singles. Beyonces single is far better than the usual boring Leona Lewis stuff. The simple video is one of the best of her career.

18. Yahoo! Music User -
Depeche Syndrome?? Come on James?? They may sell to mainly loyal fanbase here in the UK...for some unknown reason, but they continue to be huge all over the world, and I predict Wrong will give them their first UK no.1 single, and SOTU their next no1 uk album.

One of only a handful of bands that continue to break new ground, never rely on dishing out covers to get a hit, and are stronger now than when they started some 30+ years ago.....they should get outstanding brit next year I say!!! DEVOTEE 4 EVER

19. Neil -
wasn't westlife's cover of Abba's I Have A Dream a #1 at the very beginning of 2000, which would give Ulvaeus and Anderson #1's in the 70s, 80s, 90s and 2000's, ignoring the Madonna link.

20. brett -
The new Ronan Keating album is a joke and he has covered a Joshua Kadison (my all time favourite artist and writer) song. Please go on youtube and listen to the real version of 'Mama's arms' the heartfelt song written by a 15 year old who'd just lost his mother.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jay-Z for BRITs

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 11:30AM GMT

Dotmusic - Rap don to perform medley at London bash More »

More News Stories