Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending April 11th 2009

Posted Mon 6 Apr 2009 8:53AM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

Doing the double - topping both singles and albums charts simultaneously - is a feat we don't give the credit it deserves here at times, so when it does happen it is worth celebrating. Lily Allen was the first to manage the trick earlier this year, 'It's Not Me It's You' storming to the top back in February whilst its lead single was also at the head of the table. This week it is the turn of Lady Gaga for as 'Poker Face' spends a third week as the best selling single in the nation, its parent album 'The Fame' ascends to the top of the album chart. It is the first time the album has climbed higher than Number 3, a peak it scaled during its first week on sale and then again last week as the halo effect of the ever-growing popularity of 'Poker Face' did its job to perfection. Lady Gaga is the first solo American female to hit the top since Pink's 'Funhouse' landed at the summit in November last year.

The reason for lavishing this attention on it? Well to be honest, the arrival of a three month old album at the top of the charts is as close as we get to something interesting happening near the top this week. Existing hits all consolidate their deserved popularity with few new singles able to penetrate the upper reaches for now. Not that there is an air of same old, same old, about the singles chart - far from it. The other two singles in the Top 3 are hits just a couple of weeks old each, The Noisettes hanging on in second place with 'Don't Upset The Rhythm (Go Baby Go)' and AR Rahman and the Pussycat Dolls rising two to Number 3 with 'Jai Ho (You Are My Destiny)', the single now the sixth Top 3 hit for Nicole and the other ones.

Believing that all good things come to those who wait has paid off for La Roux who after a fortnight locked at Number 11 finally penetrate the Top 10, rising to Number 7 to become the only act to enter the upper reaches this week. The debate rages as to whether it is correct to refer to La Roux as "her" or "they". The name comes from singer Elly's flame red hair, yet she is always at pains to insist that she and co-producer Ben are very much equal partners in the act. Despite that the blogs on their official website are written in the first person by Elly herself and signed off as "La Roux" each time.

Yes, its quiet this week. Why do you ask?

Ah, here's a new hit. Charging to Number 17 is Just Jack with brand new single 'Embers'. Best known for his 2007 Number 2 hit 'Stars In Their Eyes', he found a follow-up hit rather harder to come by. Immediate follow-up 'Glory Days' could only limp to Number 32 and the next two singles released from major label debut 'Overtones' struggled to even find a chart toehold. Hence it is good to see him back at the more respectable end of the singles chart. 'Embers' charted last week lower down the Top 200 thanks to a one day distribution leak but is to all other intents and purposes the biggest new hit of the week. Third album 'All Night Cinema' is pencilled in for a June release.

Also flying the flag for the male end of the British singer-songwriter market is the returning Jack Penate who lands at Number 23 with brand new single 'Tonight's Today'. Like his semi-namesake Mr Alsopp above him, the Londoner is best known for one hit single in particular in 2007 and his failure to capitalise on that in the expected manner. Penate's hit was 'Torn On The Platform' which had a cup of coffee at Number 7 during the summer two years ago and which subsequently helped his debut album 'Matinee' to a Top 10 placing. His follow-up single 'Second, Minute Or Hour' was less enthusiastically received (although it did go Top 20) and by Christmas third single 'Have I Been A Fool' was largely ignored by everyone. At the risk of punning, I'm actually torn by this new single. On the one hand it is like welcoming back an old friend, his distinctive high pitched vocals and guitar lines are a welcome reminder of just why 'Torn On The Platform' was such a joy two years ago, but at the same time the rather stodgy production and general lack of sparkle kind of suggests that he's the one Jack this week who will find it hardest to shake off the one hit wonder tag, however undeserved.

The parade of returning British stars continues at Number 28 with Doves grabbing themselves a new entry with the title track from their forthcoming fourth album. It is the first chart single for the group since 2005 and heralds the release of their first album since the middle of the decade, new release 'Kingdom Of Rust' having been subject to an intense advertising campaign ahead of its release this week.
The new single is as comfortingly familiar as it is epic, instantly recognisable as a Doves single and sounding pleasingly like nothing else around it. Nonetheless this rather understated chart entry is something of a disappointment, given that the lead singles from their last two albums ('There Goes The Fear' and 'Black And White Town') were both instant Top 10 hits upon release. Could it possibly be that their long gap between releases has meant they have fallen victim to the digital divide which has seen "old school" acts whose fame was established before the download era struggle to attract the new generation of singles purchasers. Whatever the size of this hit, expect the album to get a good reception next week. Strange but true - it is 16 years to the month since the Williams brothers had their first chart hit as Sub Sub with 'Ain't No Love (Ain't No Use)'.

Down the bottom end of the Top 40, Pink grabs another chart hit with 'Please Don't Leave Me', the third single to be taken from her album 'Funhouse'. Hoping to follow predecessors 'So What' and 'Sober' into the Top 10, the single is for the moment her 18th solo hit since her debut in June 2000.

With his second album 'ROOTS' grabbing a Top 5 place upon its release this week, rapper Flo Rida traces a rather curious pattern on the singles chart. Lead single 'Right Round' continues to make the running, as although its week of glory at Number One was brief, it has been a consistent seller ever since. The track dips a place to Number 4 this week, the first time it has been out of the Top 3 since its release. Although not formally a single, the track 'Be On You' was made available on iTunes as a teaser a week ago but that track could only limp to Number 51 last week, dipping three places on this weeks chart. Instead it is outsold by what is for now the album cut of 'Sugar' which lands at Number 35 many weeks ahead of what is intended to be its promotion as the second single proper from the album. The appeal of the track is hard to miss, taking as its base the 1999 Number One hit 'Blue (Da Be Dee)' by Eiffel 65 although like 'Right Round' the track recreates the melody rather than simply sampling the original. If anything an even more immediate and catchy pop record than its predecessor, of all the new hits this week this is probably the one above all others you can expect to see propping up the Top 5 before the month is out.

Those of you getting withdrawal symptoms from a lack of singles sampling or referencing the 1980s can be reassured that your fix has arrived, thanks to the Top 40 appearance of Lady Sovereign. The closest thing we have to grime superstar, Lady Sov kind of fell victim to what is best described as the Monie Love dilemma, spiriting her talent away to an American scene entranced by her skills and in the process losing touch with the very reason she made such waves on her own manor in the first place. Never has the need to "keep it real" seemed so appropriate. The chirpy knowingness of early releases such as '9 To 5' and 'Hoodie' was replaced the soulless Americanisation of 'Love Me Or Hate Me' and 'Those Were The Days' and after her album 'Public Warning' failed to capture the imagination of many on either side of the Atlantic her much-vaunted deal with Def Jam records was torn up and she found herself scratching around for a label prepared to release her latest recordings.

So after all that, I can't be the only one glad to see the "real" Lady Sovereign back. 'So Human' sits her distinctive tones on a backing track based on the synthesiser melody from 'Close To Me' by The Cure, the single cheekily borrowing lyrics from the original to hammer the point home. This itself has caused some minor muttering in some quarters with soul singer Thomas Jules claiming he was intending to base a track around the song and had obtained clearance for the sample first, only to find some of his thunder now stolen by the grime MC. The failure of Lady Sovereign to turn underground buzz into sustained commercial success so far is something of a frustration to longterm fans of her work. Cross your fingers that Number 38 isn't as far as 'So Human' climbs.

57 Comments

1. Brian -
Also noteworthy is the fact that Lady GaGa rises to #1 on the Billboard singles chart Hot 100. This means that she has had simultaneous number UK/US 1s with both 'Just Dabce' and 'Poker Face'.

2. Rich -
The top 3 is as I expected in my comments last week. I would have liked to see A R Rahman at no.1 though. There seems to be a chronic shortage of UK artists.

3. Chig -
A couple of errors in titles; Just Jack's single was 'Starz In Their Eyes' (not 'Stars...') and Eiffel 65's bracketed bit was 'Da Ba Dee', not 'Da Be Dee'.

4. Döbler -
Pet Shop boys.... out of the top 20.. it is a shame

5. James -
James

I 'm not familiar with Jack Penate, but according to your blog, he has had a #7 and a follow up which reached the Top 20. And now he has another Top 40 hit in the bag. If thats the case then surely there is no need for him to "shake off the one hit wonder tag" for the simple reason that he can't be a one hit wonder if he has 3 Top 40 hits (inc. 2 Top 20s)!
But if you consider him a one hit wonder, then surely, by following your guidelines, Lady Sovereign is a one hit wonder also, because her only Top 10 hit is her song with the Ordinary Boys, and she hasn't had a Top 20 follow up yet...so if anything, and I were to look at the charts through your eyes, its Lady Sovereign, not Jack Penate, that needs to shake off the one hit wonder tag?

I always assumed one hit wonder meant one song in the Top 40 and nothing else ever again....what's your definition of the term James? just curious....

Anyways, I love Lady Sovereign's new single. Yes, you heard right, I actually like a song in the Top 40 for once lol #38 is still a hit in my book

Oh dear, Flo Rida has ripped off another pop hit? I find it Ironic that hardcore hip hop fans complain that everything else like infectious chart pop is rubbish and corny and yet these hipp hop artists are continously ripping off old chart hits. Suddenly, when a hip hop artists samples a pop hit, its sounds good, thinks the hardcore hip hop fans...poor misguided souls...

La Roux is certainly a grower, but I have a strange feeling I have heard the song (or at least the beat) somewhere else before...is it a cover or something?

What's taking Franz Ferdinand so long to reach the official Top 20? Its been bouncing up and down the Top 20 on itunes for weeks...

Can't everyone move on from Kings of Leon now?

6. James -
oh, btw Fearne Cotton flew solo yesterday. As usual, very opinionated and went off topic alot of times. At one point the discussion was good names for horses....positive thing to say though, is that she didn't skip as many songs a Reggie would if he did the show by himself...

Anyways, she seems to constantly praise that "I Love College" song. She said something like it has the same summer vibe as a Will Smith track or something like that...what? she's serious? Its just someone, with a bored sounding and uninspired voice, slowly talking over a beat for a few minutes...yeah, i can feel those summer vibes too Fearne...:S

7. James Masterton -
I'm using "one hit wonder" in its loosest possible form, as you may have guessed. The clue is the word "label" or "tag" as it is possible to be branded as someone who has only had one hit despite having others.

The acid test - would the casual listener be able to name or recognise more than one of their hits? Jack Penate may have charted several singles, but only his first actually had a mainstream impact and is still likely to be played occasionally on the radio. Hence he is a "one hit wonder" to people other than the likes of you or I who know much better...

8. James -
fair point James. Fair point. I'll never question your ideas again lol

Take care man!

9. Yahoo! Music User -
Post 6 - The Franz Ferninand single is released physically today, with a barrage of new remixes spread over 7", 12" and CD. This should give it fresh impetus and hopefully send it into the top ten.

As for the poor chart position of Doves, they've actually never been a big singles band - both their top ten singles ('There Goes The Fear' and 'Black And White Town') went straight in and out of the charts. In the current climate, where indie rock struggles in the singles chart, a #28 position is probably to be expected. I think that fans will be more interested in the LP, which has received strong reviews. Given last year's success for Elbow, another northern band often compared to Doves, the album is likely to do very well indeed.

10. Armand Rahim -
This is what has become of US's Rap songs..sampling oof European tunes

TI & Rihana did it first with Live Your Life and now we have Florida with 2 tracks

What's next? Sampling the country tunes? So much for originality!!!

By the way, go check out Lady Gaga's remix version of Poker Face. The original is not bad but the remixes are def the better ones

11. Sean -
Funny blog this week James - good job with limited material. It will be interesting to see whether you get any abuse from PCD fans.

I'm working on a theory to explain the relatively poor showing of indie bands in the singles chart. With physical albums released within one or two weeks of the lead single, and the single difficult (or impossible) to obtain in physical format, I suspect potential buyers of music by the likes of Doves and Franz Ferdinand are simply waiting for the album. Regardless of how they listen to music (e.g. on a CD player, on an i-Pod), the digital download of a single becomes a 79p expense which has expired after 1 or 2 weeks. It therefore seems a pointless exercise to download a single if you intend to buy the album anyway. In the days of CD singles, there was actually something tangible to buy, which seemed to continue to have a value after the album had been released. Not any more.

So, why does this affect certain acts more than others ? Well, it is back to the type of buyer. I imagine that indie rock is generally purchased by slightly older people than pop and r'n'b. They are, therefore, more likely to plan the greater expense of an album purchase, than selectively choosing single tracks for download. For a younger person, an album is possibly slightly less affordable, whilst having the latest "cool" tune on your i-Pod is more relevant.

Importantly, I'm not suggesting one or other is better, I'm simply trying to articulate what may be happening.

I wonder if others agree with my attempted explanation ?

12. Michelle -
shireblogger: I generally agree with your suggestions as to the peculiar decline of guitar bands in the singles chart. However, a lot of the bands are seeing significantly reduced album, as well as single, sales. Razorlight, Franz Ferdinand, Kaiser Chiefs - their normally reliable album sales collapsed last time out. There is something to be said about fashion being the key reason - guitar/indie music just isn't that popular at the moment.

That said, the masses will always have one exception to any rule. Kings of Leon's almost freakish, brilliantly marketed, success is the UK's designated exception to this rule. Even my missus likes them and she buys about 0.5 albums a year...

13. Yahoo! Music User -
I agree with both 11 and 12 but I would also say the loss of the physical single as a tangible purchase has contributed to the lost album sales.

When singles were impulse purchases in shops/supermarkets, it was possible for a band to pick up new fans as someone might spend £1.99 and take the chance on a band they haven't bought before, then subsequently buy the album.

This kind of purchaser won't take the time to do the equivalent on a download site so the band has effectively lost both singles and albums sales and only sell to their fanbase. A new generation of the Depeche Mode/PSB effect ... apart from the exception to the rule, Kings Of Leon, I can't see how a new indie band would gather new fans on the singles chart.

14. Sean -
billingsleym - You make a good point about the collapse of album sales for Razorlight, FF, KC etc. Perhaps the market has been saturated with this type of music ? I think Kings Of Leon sound significantly different from the British bands, and are pretty much the only big selling act playing swampy lo-fi country rock at the moment. Expect a whole bunch of bandwagon jumpers to appear in the next 12 months.

I think we are in one of those cycles where pop is gaining ground over rock, and we may even be witnessing the green shoots of the latest dance music revival.

15. Colin -
I agree with 11-13 to a certain extent but the other feature is the higher sales that are needed for a top 20 or even a top 40 hit compared to 3-4 years ago. An indie type band would have top heavy 1 week sales and any track with the slightest bit of a hype or profile would make the top 40 and then drop out in 2- 3 weeks. In the days of CDUk & TOTp this translated into appearances and this boosted the bands profile again and helped sell albums.

Now single sales are no longer 1 week heavy some tracks can be available for several weeks before even getting near the top 75 eg Bat For Lashes this week which is now #57 I think. If she had all those sales she has already had over the last 5 weeks or so in one week she would easily be in the top 20.

Or another example is Franz Ferdinand they have spent 3 weeks in the 20-30 area before that it had been downloaded as an album track in small numbers since the album was released. But again if they had all been 1 week easily top 10 but then it would have plummetted like a stone.

I know this is getting long but watch Doves, it will climb next week instead of drop 2nd week like every other Doves single. Mark my words.

16. James -
I've ranted about this before, but surely lack of promotion is another (key) factor thats contributing to the decline in indie music? I bet most of these indie bands would fare much better if they actually went out and promoted their music a bit more...does everyone really expect a song to become a hit just because Radio and music channels will play them non stop? It doesn't work like that. How do artists expect to sell music to people beyond their fanbase if they aren't even getting up to promote it?

I think the lack of promotion is one of the most (if not, THE most) important factor thats causing indie bands to miss out...

17. Colin -
Where do they promote Hunj008, there's only Jonathan Ross,Jools Holland and Reality/ talent shows??

We need mainstream music shows back on terrestrial tv!!

18. Iain -
I agree with both huntj008 and thorne175.

The only reason Franz Ferdinand have been in the top 30 for the past 3 weeks is because of the itunes advert and their performance on Ant & Dec a few weeks back. Without this exposure 'No You Girls' would probably only just dent the top 40 this coming week. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad the track is doing relatively well because it's a great tune.

It will be very interesting to see how Calvin Harris does with his new track. And Depeche Mode syndrome theories will be tested again with the release of 'Wrong'.

19. Yahoo! Music User -
Ok, James, you were right last week about mentioning that the pet shop boys album will nosdedive this week, and it has dropped from 4 to 21, which is a great shame really, as it is a cracking album, and is easily as good as their 1980's albums, which sold millions.
Also the new song from The Doves is awesome, but sadly probably won't climb next week, but then again, strange things are happening, what with Franz Ferdinand climbing the charts last week for the very first time in their career, and this week, White Lies climb 1 place to 33, and i expected that to drop well out of the 40.
It would've been great to have seen The Noisettes making number 1 this week, as we need more British acts/artists at the top, although i do actually like the Lady Gaga song.
I see that sex on fire has gone up yet again, this time from 31 to 27, and use somebody still at 15, but their latest song, revelry has already dropped out of the top 40 after only 3 or 4 weeks.
Maybe they won't release any more songs from the album.

20. Yahoo! Music User -
I was referring to Kings Of Leon, regarding my previous comments about Sex on fire going back up again, for those who have not been listening or taken any notice of the charts for the past year or so, (ok, slight exaggeration, but it seems like a year)
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
195
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jay-Z for BRITs

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 11:30AM GMT

Dotmusic - Rap don to perform medley at London bash More »

More News Stories