Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending June 20th 2009

Posted Mon 15 Jun 2009 10:07AM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

A large part of the fun of chart-watching is waiting to spot the unusual. You know, the things that only happen every once in a while, the new benchmarks and the strange statistical quirks that are thrown up by a listing that is updated on a weekly basis. Sometimes you get weeks like this which make all the dull times in between seem worth the while - for on this weeks singles chart there are no less than four, in fact make that five, extraordinary events which whilst they may not be unique are certainly very unusual.

Let's start with the very top of the singles chart for we have a quite spectacular debut at Number One. It seems almost odd to suggest that Pixie Lott has been groomed for stardom for several years, given that she is barely 18 years old, but the truth of the matter is that her emergence into the mainstream comes after she has spent four years in development, notoriously signing her first management contract when she was just 14. Her debut single is 'Mama Do', a glorious example of just what has made the starlet such a sensation, with one listen answering all the questions people might have as to why this unknown teenager has flown to the top of the chart with her very first release. She has a rich, velvety voice which is part Joss Stone and part Amy Winehouse whilst 'Mama Do' is the most richly soulful Number One single since 'Mercy', one of those songs that wraps itself around you and all but compels you to settle back and lose yourself in its atmosphere.

Plus it is with Pixie Lott that we get extraordinary event number 1 for she achieves the unusual feat of charting both the a-side and b-side of her single at the same time. Languishing down the singles chart at Number 52 is her rendition of Kings Of Leon's 'Use Somebody' available as Track 2 to those who buy it on iTunes. This isn't a totally unique occurrence, the same thing happening to Leona Lewis back in 2007 when 'Forgiveness' landed just outside the Top 40 in the same week that 'Bleeding Love' debuted at the top, nonetheless it is still quite baffling as to how this can come about. 'Use Somebody' has only charted because people are buying it as a standalone track, selecting it for individual purchase from an online store. It is surely inconceivable that people are only buying the throwaway b-side and not the lead track so it must be a consequence of purchasers snapping up both - and thus wasting money. 'Mama Do' is available as a digital bundle, listed on iTunes for £1.49 for both tracks together. Sales of that will have counted towards the chart position of 'Mama Do' alone. Therefore the only way 'Lose Somebody' has charted is if people have bought the 79p standalone of the a-side and then gone back to repurchase the b-side, thus spending a total of £1.58 and costing themselves 9p in the process. Hey, there is a recession on and every penny counts surely.

Extraordinary event number 2 is a minor one, but worth noting nonetheless. Languishing at Number 5 is 'Red' from Daniel Merriweather which has remained locked in the same position ever since it was released. This week is thus the single's fourth straight week at Number 5. Whilst singles spending extended periods at Number One and even Number 2 is not so unusual, it is something quite notable for a record to lock at the same mid-chart position for so long, considering there are so many other places for it to go. For those who care and who like to keep track of these things, 'Red' is the first single to spend four straight weeks at Number 5 since 'How To Save A Life' by The Fray in early 2007.

The second highest new entry on the singles chart lands at Number 7, a single which in many ways was just as anticipated as the Pixie Lott single. Kelly Rowland currently finds herself without a record deal and casting around for new projects, but to fill the time she agreed to supply vocals for 'When Love Takes Over', the brand new single from French producer David Guetta. No ordinary club single this, 'When Love Takes Over' is an inspiring pop record based heavily around the piano riff from 'Clocks' by Coldplay. The single is David Guetta's third Top 10 hit and his biggest chart smash since 'Love Don't Get Me Go (Walking Away)' hit Number 3 in August 2006. For Kelly Rowland it is her first chart single since 'Daylight' hit Number 14 last year and her sixth non-Destiny's Child Top 10 single.

The single would have almost certainly have charted higher had it been available for a whole week, but it originally wasn't meant to be available last week at all. 'When Love Takes Over' was raced online in a panic when not one but two spoiler (and indeed near-identical) cover versions started to race up the iTunes rankings and threatened to have a negatively impact on the "official" version. So here indeed is extraordinary event number 3 for there are two different versions of the song inside the Top 40 this week as the note for note remake by Ari L lands at Number 22. It is extraordinary, but by no means unique as almost exactly a year ago the same thing happened to Katy Perry's 'I Kissed A Girl' which was denied the chance to debut at the top of the charts by a midweek rush release to see off a spoiler version by Nicki Bliss which was climbing the chart at the same time.

Topping the album chart this week with few surprises are Kasabian who land their second Number One album in a row with 'West Ryder Pauper Lunatic Asylum', hard on the heels of 2006s 'Empire'. Lead single 'Fire' slips down the chart slightly in its wake, dipping 3-8 but the availability of the other tracks from the album means it spawns its very own halo hit as cherrypicked sales of lead track 'Underdog' are enough to see it land at Number 32. The popularity of the non-single track is thanks to its use in a series of TV commercials for Sony and so it is perhaps no surprise that people were keen to snap it up the moment it was available in its own right. Chalk this up as extraordinary event number 4 then, particularly as 'Underdog' isn't scheduled for the moment to be an official single, 'Where Did All The Love Go' scheduled to be the album's next formal release.

Two singles rush the Top 40 from lower down the chart this week and in a strange coincidence they both create extraordinary event number 5. Leading the charge is Lady Gaga's third single 'Paparazzi' which was finally granted a physical release last week and so gets the boost in sales it needed to become a hit single properly, vaulting 30 places to Number 13. In the process she lands herself consecutive chart positions, with its predecessor 'Poker Face' sitting pretty at Number 14. The exact same thing happens to the Pussycat Dolls who make an identical 30 place climb with new single 'Hush Hush' to sit at Number 25. That just happens to be one place below their last single 'Jai Ho' leaving the girls to chart at both 24 and 25 in the most tidy way possible.

Naturally all of this means that the remaining new singles on the chart risk being something of an anticlimax, having nothing particularly remarkable about them. For the record though, we should acknowledge the impressive debut of 'New Divide' which gives Linkin Park their first standalone hit single in almost two years. The track serves as the theme to the new Transformers movie 'Revenge Of The Fallen', thus continuing the group's association with the movie franchise after 2007 single 'What I've Done' appeared in the first instalment. With no announcement yet made on a new Linkin Park album, this one-off single may stick around for a little while, especially once the film hits the cinemas here.

One place below at Number 21 is a single which many are hoping will give Jordin Sparks her biggest worldwide success yet. 'Battlefield' is the title track from her second album and caused an online stir the moment it was first unveiled back in May. Simply put it is her most lavish and elaborately constructed production yet, a multi-layered track with an anthemic chorus that you feel needs a stadium full of flag-waving supporters to contain it. Jordin Sparks has suffered in the past from being given some rather weedy songs to sing, but this one is her most worthwhile yet. The only downside (and there has to be one naturally) is that you cannot escape the feeling you may have heard it all before. The problem is that co-writer Ryan Tedder appears to be suffering from what we in the business call Gregg Alexander disease, a condition which means you write one great song and then get stuck in a rut of churning out endless clones of it. Hence whilst 'Battlefield' may be a grand, epic and potentially award-winning track, musically it isn't so different from similarly anthemic and epic songs such as 'Halo' and 'Bleeding Love' which you will note were all co-written and produced by the OneRepublic frontman and which all use a similar formula - right down to the rhythm track. Mix it up a bit, please!

Finally for this week, Number 33 is the rather surprising low entry point for one of the most referenced singles of the last six months. 'The Show' is the debut single from Australian actress Lenka and a single which which had found itself used as a popular culture reference in TV shows and in commercials all over the world. Musically it is fun and engaging, starting off with just her and a piano before building up to a climax with a full band. For those of us who have watched with frustration as acts such as Regina Spektor fail to gain a commercial toehold, it is something of a joy to see a multi-layered anti-folk track such as this one make a chart appearance. I'm kind of hoping this is just the start of big things for this single, but there is always the fear that this is one of those gleefully good singles that simply falls by the wayside and remains a well-kept secret. Here's hoping anyway.

53 Comments

1. D -
great new number 1 this week- at last something with a melody!. Love the David Guetta/Kelly Rowland collaboration. Don't get Daniel Merriweather- formulaic- heard it all before- bit like Jordin Sparks- 3rd rate r&b. Not surprised at GaGa only landing a 13 spot- been hanging around for weeks and album has sold in bucketfuls. Notice Eurovision track Fairytale has dropped out the top 100- is this a new record for shortest stay in top 100 for a top 10 single- 3 weeks in total. Why is Journey still hanging around in chart- have I missed something? is it being used in a commercial? Love the Lenka track. Interesting to see the re-emergence of uk cover versions of us tracks hitting th chart and denting sales of the originals- Dionne Warwick and the Drifters were the biggest losers in the 60s at the hands of pale imitations by uk artists including Cilla Balck, Cliff Bennett, Sandie Shaw to name but a few. Blue Magic lost out to Barry Briggs in the 70s and Millie Jackson to Susan Cadogan in a spate of reggae covers of us soul hits. Iteresting to see such a low entry on the album chart for Rod Stewart & the Faces best of compilation despite containing somany classic tracks and a strong advertising campaign including tv spots- yet old Jim Reeves (who's appalling sentimental Distant Drums kept both the Who and the Supremes [still the benchmark for all girl groups[ from scoring number 1) is still hanging in there at the top of the chart- amazing since most of the people who were big reeves fans in the 60s must surely have gone to join him in that big ol' Opry in the sky.

2. Yahoo! Music User -
Predicts the number one! Last Monday I said she would do it and she has.
Does anyone know if the CD single credits AA for use somebody?
B-Side or not the sales should be grouped together.

Just caught the end of what was Hit 40uk, but it's no longer called that and they have new presenters and they had the David Guetta track top! The DJ kept saying the chart you can change or words to that effect. This means that it must be very different to the BBC chart I guess?

3. Yahoo! Music User -
Great commentary as usual, but I can't hear a resemblence in tune between Clocks and When love takes over myself.

4. Yahoo! Music User -
Just checked out the website and it's called THE BIG TOP 40 and they clearly took my advice on board a few weeks ago on this blog and linked with the Tunes!
Here's how they say the chart now runs:

"The Big Top 40 Show is powered by iTunes, but what does that actually mean?
Well, it means that every time you click to download a song from iTunes, Apple track your purchase and use it to produce a list of the fastest selling songs of the moment.
We use this data to build the Big Top 40 and because this data is live and compiled in real-time, it means that the Big Top 40 chart is always changing and updating right up until the moment when we lock down the top 10 on a Sunday evening.
Chart positions 40 to 11 are compiled using a mix of iTunes sales data and radio airplay, the top ten songs is purely complied from live iTunes sales data. This means that while the show is on air, you can download your favourite songs and influence the top 10."

5. Yahoo! Music User -
Re: comment 2.

That new 'interactive' Capital Top 40 show was just ridiculous. They announced Paparazzi at no.21 and within the hour they were playing it at no.9!! Although Kasabian's Fire was inside the Top 10 at the start of the show, this was later glossed over and there was no mention of it in the countdown.

Two questions
1. How can the same song occupy two places in the Top 40 within the space of an hour?
2. How can a song which was Top Ten at 4pm, drop out of the Top 40 by 6pm?

Consider the following scenario...
Capital Radio plays the songs between 21 and 40. This results in a spate of downloads for these tracks. By 6pm, ten songs which have already been played between 21 and 40 manage to pick up sufficient sales to outsell the songs that were in the Top Ten at 4pm. That would mean that the entire 4pm Top Ten would disappear from the charts by 6pm, whilst they re-play a whole load of songs which have previously been played between 21 and 40.

It's just nuts!!!

6. D -
graham 161534
interesting to find out how the 'alternative' new top 40 is compiled. No reference to people downloading form other providers such as amazon or hmv for example. Although i tunes is by far the biggest online retailer the chart is never going to be as accurate since a few hundred copies sold but not included can have a serious effect- both positive and negative - a tracks chart position. Yes it has always been the case I hear many cry- back in the day when record stores were 'sampled' and many independent specialist shops- particularly indie, reggae and r&b- were not included in the tally. But at the end of the day- does it really matter since everyone still refers the official chart as the industry standard? It may ultimately influence how the official chart is compiled- but it has and always will be a sideshow to the main event- the official top 100. Even the commercial djs refer to the official uk chart when doing their nostalgia spots

7. D -
post 5-
wow! what a complete and utter mess! Bet there is a post incident review of the disaster as we type- a few heads must surely roll! Never ever saw the point of the commercial stations chart- always seemed a joke to me. This latest revamped format is obviously an ill conceived concept has ended in a disasterous launch- just plain stupid to be counting the downloads made during broadcast- there has to be a cut off point somewhere and it has to be 4pm if they the chart is to to have any credibilty. Curiosity means I might listen to the train wreck next week lol!

8. Darrin -
Congratulations r in order for Lily Allen this week who despite having already dropped out of the UK top10 vaults 6-3 in the Aussie singles chart with not fair. The British superstar who is currently touring Australia can now boast back2back top3 hits a feat not managed by a British female artist since the nineties perhaps.

9. Lee -
The Big Top 40 show is as bad as ever. Mixing airplay in for some tracks and then just sales for the top 10 - how can you have a chart based on that? Answer you can't. The same mistake the networked chart show has had for years.

Don't get me wrong - I'm happy for David Guetta to be number one on the Big Top 40. But Pixie Lott seems to have sold 58840 downloads so it must prove that many people buy their music from places other than itunes.

And no disrepect, Graham, but I don't think anyone doubted she would be number one this week. A stale week before with a song going back up to number one, and then this week with one of pop's new talents releasing her much hyped song - kind of a one horse race.

10. Geoff -
Pixie Lott b-side of cd single is 'Want You' so I guess people are downloading 'Use Somebody' because of that.

11. Imaani B -
It gets worse...

I cannot comprehend how airplay can be added to the mix? Thats a seperate listing all-together surely? I thought the top 40 was about the best SELLING tracks not the most played? I personally have always loved tuning in to listen to the most popular tracks of the week which have been BOUGHT by the British public as it is a true reflection of what is LIKED by the British public...

Radio stations can now influence this by adding in airplay for the rest of the top 40? How crap. I believe this should be kept seperate.

As for the top 40.....Im glad we have a new number 1. Its brilliant and i also love the Kelly Rowland and David Guetta collaboration. Shame on the spoiler version....there always has to be one.

Good to see Agnes going back up the chart a place. Shes going to have a long run in the top 10 if the summer weather continues. It was like that back in 1996 when the hot weather saw sales for Summery dance tracks by Ultra Nate and Rosie Gaines keep them afloat in the top 10 for a while.

I really want little boots to do really well but at the moment she hasnt penetrated the top 10! I hope Empire of the Sun do really well also. Very summery and Mika'ish...

Have been loving the DeadMau5 track for some time now and good to see it still in the top 30.

How long has Jason Mraz spent in the top 75 now? Who the hell is still buying it?!

12. jerry -
re post 1 : sorry Dwillpower, but even though The Who, infamously never reached the number 1 slot ever, The Supremes did...with Baby Love...

13. Rik -
If we forget the latest stupidity that is 'The Big Top 40 Show' or whatever this weeks name is, the actual official chart is pretty good this week. I seem to recall earlier in the year a lot of negative comments on this blog regarding dance music, including from James, but it is back with a bang again recently with Calvin Harris, Deadmau5, Agnes and next weeks number 1 with David Guetta. Also a big new entry next week from The Freemasons too! ... Being an ex- DJ I always prefer Dance to the current plodding R&B / Hip Hop formulaic stuff!!

14. Simon -
The BBC Top 40 show - did anyone catch it yesterday? The usual self-obsessed ramblings of the vacuous Fearne Cotton were replaced by some woman from Coronation Street (Michelle Keaton? Keegan?) who - guess what - could actually speak! She could hold a conversation, had some interesting banter with Reggie (who holds 95% of the brain cells in that studio when Cotton is around) in whom she brought out a much more entertaining personality than we normally see from him as he is usually cowed by Cotton's presence (showing her respect / deference due to being old mates?). And to cap it all, said Corrie lady actually seemed to understand the concept of the chart and presented it with much more interest than Cotton, who usually spends most of the show talking about cakes, or in fact anything but the chart itself. Please BBC, bring this Corrie lassie in as a permanent replacement for Cotton. For the first time since before Wes Butters I actually didn't turn the volume down between songs!

15. Gary -
Hello, It shows on the Offical Top 100 Chart that Clubbers Guide 2009 is at no.97 in the Singles Chart, Surely this is a Typo?

16. Robin T -
Post 1 'Raving I'm Raving' by Shut Up and Dance made number two but only spent two weeks in the Top 100.

It entered the charts at number two, but no more copies were pressed due to copyright reasons (it was based around Marc Cohen's 'Walking In Memphis' without permission).

The track dropped to 14 the following week based on the copies remaining in store but there weren't any left after that so it dropped out completely!

17. D -
post 12 jerryhershal
yes Jerry as a Motown/Supremes and chart fanatic I am well aware that the girls hit No1 in 1964 with Baby Love- the first girl group ever to do so in the UK and the 2nd of their 12 US Billboard No 1 hits scored between 1964-69- only the Beatles and Elvis scored a greater number of No1 hits in the US. Unfortunately the significant contribution made by Motown and the Supremes in the development of poular music and culturally in the context of civil rights is often marginalised by the mainly white rock/indie oriented music press. I referred to Distant Drums keeping I'm aBoy' and 'You Can't Hurry Love' from the No1 spot (depending on which chart you followed- before it was made official by the BBC).

18. Robin T -
Here's a quiz question that I don't know the answer to!

Is Pixie Lott the first person born in the 1990's to write a number one hit? She was born on 12 January 1991.

Does anyone know if this is true, or did someone else get there first?

Tinchy Stryder is older (born 1987), and N-Dubz don't count as they were only guests on 'Number One.'

19. Yahoo! Music User -
re post 15:
Yes, I was wondering too. If this is indeed a typo, then it should be corrected and not left as it stands. What is the correct #100 then (the song which currently sits at #101)?
By the way: Is there any source for positions 101-200 (preferably on the net) other than the overpriced chartsplus?

20. Yahoo! Music User -
post 13 - if by "the freemasons" you mean Simon Cowell then "oh good god"... i wouldn't be surprised if he was one...

but enough of New World Order conspiracies, great chart this week and a well deserved #1. I too see no comparison between Coldplay's "Clocks" and "When Love Takes Over"...

Paparazzi went physical already? I thought it wasn't for another few weeks? regardless, it will probably climb next week...

post 14 - agreed, the corrie women was much more interesting than Fearne Cotton, and as you said at least showed interest in what she was doing...even McFly, who presented it a little while back, seemed more interested in what they were doing than miss Cotton...sadly, it doesn't matter if Fearne & Reggie go any time soon anyway...all the current Radio 1 DJs would be naff choices for replacement, in that we'd still get the same non-chart related/childish banter before the DJ remembers what they are suppose to be doing in the first place...

...Dance music can be just as formulaic as hip-hop/rnb... to me, Scooter and Basshunter are pretty much the same artist...
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
120
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
46
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
39
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
183
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
218
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Boyzone honoured by gay group

world entertainment news -
Sat 7 Nov 2009 11:26AM GMT

world entertainment news - Irish pop group Boyzone have been honoured by gay rights campaigners in London - with officials preparing a special tribute for late member Stephen Gately. More »

More News Stories