Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending June 27th 2009

Posted Mon 22 Jun 2009 9:15AM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

For those continually bemoaning that even in this age of upward mobility you still need to enter at the very top to make Number One on the singles chart, there is some welcome news this week as a record instead makes an impressive six place climb to the top. Naturally things are never that quite straightforward, for the record in question is 'When Love Takes Over' by David Guetta and Kelly Rowland which only charted at Number 7 last week thanks to a midweek rush release to counter the effect of a spoiler cover version. With all formats of the single now available its presence at the top comes as little surprise but it is still a moment to savour nonetheless. This track is without a shadow of a doubt one of the anthems of the summer, one of the tracks by which the holiday of 2009 will be defined - and naturally it is a tremendous uplifting pop record to boot. It is the first ever Number One single for David Guetta and with this track he becomes the first Frenchman to top the UK charts since Romain Tranchart and Yann Destagnol of Modjo in September 2000. For Kelly Rowland it is her second extra-Destiny's Child Number One single and arrives almost seven years after her first, 'Dilemma' on which she duetted alongside Nelly.

The only new arrivals inside the singles Top 10 are both singles motoring up from the lower reaches. Leading the charge is 'Paparazzi' by Lady Gaga which moves 13-8, its surge in support coming not as I erroneously suggested last week thanks to its physical availability (which is due in a couple of weeks) but for the rather more straightforward reason that its video finally went into widespread circulation and thus ensuring it gained TV airplay. The single is naturally now her third Top 10 single in a row.

One place behind at Number 9 is 'Said It All' from Take That which surges up the singles chart from its rather lowly Number 48 placing last week. The epic ballad is the third single lifted from their album 'The Circus' and niftily beats out the Number 14 peak of their last single 'Up All Night'. The single is their 18th Top 10 hit, a statistic which naturally kind of pales into insignificance next to their 11 Number One hits. Whilst writing this on Sunday night I was entertained to note that the Wikipedia entry for the song contained the wonderfully optimistic line: "there is speculation that it will make number-one in the UK Singles Chart". Needless to say there is no source or attribution for this, so let's give them some speculation that can be referenced back: it won't.

It is clubland that provides us with the highest new entry on the singles chart, with 'Heartbreak (Make Me A Dancer)' smashing in to Number 15 for the Freemasons and their special guest star Sophie Ellis Bextor. Fans of the singer will be instantly familiar with the track as it premiered online well over a year ago as an example of some of the work in progress of her as yet untitled fourth album. With said long player still yet to surface, 'Heartbreak...' has instead emerged commercially with full credit given to the production wizards who have helped to create it. Make no mistake though this is every inch a starring vehicle for the pouting singer herself, an intoxicating mid-tempo Eurodisco track which knocks just about everything she has put her name to in the last few years to the ground. The single is Sophie Ellis-Bextor's first chart hit since 2007 and her biggest hit single since 'Catch You' was a Top 10 hit in February that year. The Freemasons have only once had a Top 10 hit as a credited act, 'Uninvited' hitting Number 8 in October 2007. Make no mistake, this single is set to join those ranks in seven days time.

Yet another hot new female act takes a bow this week, Paloma Faith arriving at an impressive Number 17 with debut single 'Stone Cold Sober'. The singer and actress is another Winehouse-alike with a yowling jazz voice which wraps itself around this brass-soaked single in a far from unpleasant manner. It isn't the most conventional pop record you will hear all summer but is no less brilliant for all that, so have another gratuitous video embed so you can appreciate it properly.

Lower down the bottom end of the Top 40 there is a new entry for Jack Penate with 'Be The One', his second single of the year landing at Number 35 following April hit 'Tonight's Today'. This new track suffers the same fate as the first, sounding scrappy and thrown together compared to the joyous slices of music that heralded his 2007 debut. Meanwhile just one place below at Number 36 is '15 Minutes', the debut chart single from next big thing act The Yeah You's. The duo comprise guitarist Nick Ingram and keyboard player Mike Kintish and both combine their voices in an intoxicating harmony which in truth isn't a million miles away from that of Gary Barlow and the rest of Take That. For an act which had gathered its fair share of praise in the credible press, they are almost startlingly commercial with '15 Minutes' more than holding its own as one of the best pop singles you have heard all week in a chart which is fairly stuffed full of them. I'm hoping this chart placing isn't reflective of a here today and gone tomorrow chart run. '15 Minutes' deserves to be Top 20 with some amount of urgency.

There is no change at the top of the album chart with Kasabian sitting pretty for a second week. Instead the biggest surprise is the Number 4 arrival of 'Let It Roll', a retrospective hits collection of the entire solo career of the late George Harrison. The album features all of his solo hits as well as some live recordings from the celebrated charity Concert For Bangladesh which he staged in 1971. The collection is his highest charting album since 'Living In The Material World' made Number 3 when first released in 1973. Even his 1987 "comeback" album 'Cloud Nine' (and source to 'Let It Roll's' lead track 'Got My Mind Set On You') only reached Number 10.

Finally it would be wrong to let this week pass without a brief acknowledgement of the widely reported news story that another possible change to the way record charts are compiled is on the way, with the Official Charts Company only too aware of the growing popularity of online streaming services such as Spotify and We7 and the need to somehow take online listens rather than actual purchases in order to assess the relative popularity of pieces of music. In typical sensationalist fashion the BBC headline "Top 40 faces new digital shakeup" suggests that this integration is almost a fait accompli and will be happening now, quotes later in the piece from OCC director Martin Talbot pointing out that the actual inclusion of streaming figures might be as long as five years away, the presence of the services in the market simply being something they are aware of and working towards tracking officially. Nonetheless if streaming data does ever come onstream it will be possibly the most dramatic sea change in the British charts ever. For a long time in the 80s and early 90s there were calls from some quarters for airplay data to be used as part of the chart compilation process as it is in America, the industry instead electing to retain the principle that the chart tracked actual permanent purchases and nothing else. The possibility does exist now though that physical (or even digital) ownership of music is going to become less and less necessary with a vast cloud of music able to follow you everywhere to be heard on demand. It is that kind of future that the whole industry will have to embrace. In the meantime the digital sales of tracks just keep on rising... Music purchasing to own isn't going to go away just yet.

62 Comments

1. minardifan -
Really pleased to see David Guetta and Kelly Rowland reach number one with such a great dance tune, should help her land a new record deal.

Also pleased to see Take That return to the Top 10, with quite a subdued song.

But a real shame to see Depeche Mode chart in the low 50s, should this song plummet next week, it will be their first single since Little 15 (an import) to fail to make the Top 30. Seem no-one is that interested in Depeche singles at the moment?

2. Matthew -
Very glad that Kelly Rowland has managed another Number One, as much as I like Beyonce I do prefer Miss Rowland! Great to see Sophie Ellis Bextor in the chart . . . can't wait for her 4th studio album which I hope will surface soon! The romours of airplay being included in the charts is not something I like to hear, I feel a lot of acts will miss out because radio will not play them. There is songs radio play over and over again and most probabaly have a track that will last for years in the chart!

3. Humboldt -
minardifan - I love Depeche Mode too but 'Peace' is their 3rd single not to make the top 30. The others were:

Dreaming Of Me (57)
Something To Do (75)

4. Muhammad -
Little Boots took a massive plunge from 5 to 40.

5. C -
Good commentary but I think you're a bit harsh on Jack Penate. As all good Guardian readers know, his new stuff is a complete rebirth that has transformed him from an irritating cockney knees-up man into a wide-eyed, genre-blending musical visionary. I just think it sounds a bit like Friendly Fires.

6. D -
A hnaful of new entries make the top 100 this wee. Great new no1 from D Guetta a real summer dance anthem with fantastic diva vocals from Kelly R- unlike the consistently bland souless vocals that Sophie E B turns out on the Freemasons track- I love the Freemasons but this is far from their best work and yet looks set to give them their highest chart placing. Wish they would work with old school divas like Donna Summer, Diana Ross or even Dame Shirley- now that would be an interesting collaboration! Agnes continues to yo-yo between 3rd & 4th slot- another great dance track that will be around all summer. Take That doing well on the back of their spectacular tour- awesome guys! with several tracks rising in the 100. GaGa continues to conquer the world with another great track- what will her mext album be like? Will she have longevity- reminds me of Madonna's arrival back in the 80s. Must admit that Jordin sparks and Paulo Nutini's current hits have grown on me. Surely a disappointing yet predictably low chart placing for Blazing Squad. The hype surrounding the Jonas Brothers still refuses to transfer into record sales in the UK- thank god. Depeche Mode- why do they bother? Apart from hardcore fans they are irrelevant today much as Sir Paul McCartney is. Why is an old 80s Journey track climbing the chart- have I missed something? Insomnia alert- James Blunt climbs to 92- am I the only person who finds this guys vocals as irritating as finger nails being scratched across polystyrene?

7. this charming man -
I did notice Little Boots dropping like an anvil in the album charts. I guess she won't be filling the O2 in 25 years' time, then...
Pet Shop Boys did fill it last Friday, so they might not worry too much about their latest single (which I think is an average PSB-by-numbers, before someone accuses me of being baised) being a bit of a flop.

Also, as an early promoter of the Radio 1 Chart Show hate campaign, imagine my distress when I found out that I share a birthday with both Reggie Yates and Joel (of JK & Joel "fame")

I listened to the end of the show last night, what a disgrace...

8. Michelle -
cpalmer99@ymail.com: Agree that the Jack Penate criticism is harsh. It might have been a cynical 'new direction' he's taken, but it sounds unusual and enjoyable. Surely it's better than another raft of 'gorblimey' sickly-sweet pop with a dodgy ska aftertaste.

9. Malcolm -
I'm a bit concerned to see that chart placings in the future may take into consideration radio airplay. As we all know, radio only play a select quota of songs each day based on their own subjective opinions. This means that the likes of acts not considered suitable for radio stations will chart lower even though they may sell more digital or physical purchases. By all means have an airplay chart (but will there be two, one for the BBC and another for commercial like the two different charts we have now?) but keep the sales chart separate (which could involve Spotify listens et al) and be a true chart based on the public's choice and not station controllers.

10. Yahoo! Music User -
I enjoy the new song of David Guetta. And if you are open-minded and like "House music" I invite you to discover my musical universe and my last remixed song on: www.myspace.com/ninozik

11. Whoz -
a.kay-my plimsoles this guy will give tinchy stryder a run for his money
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A45zXR895n4&feature=related

12. D -
latest news on a review of how the official chats co are considering a change to chart compilation rules- info taken from post on digital spy site:

Top 40 'may include streaming services'
Monday, June 22 2009, 10:55 BST
By Mayer Nissim, Entertainment Reporter
The UK Top 40 may soon reflect tracks listened to via subscription and streaming sites as well as individual sales, it has emerged.

The Official UK Charts Company said that the inclusion of such services is inevitable, but added that it will not happen for at least a year and could take up to two decades, the BBC reports.

It has been suggested that songs streamed will carry less weight per listen than actual sales of tracks.

Official Charts Company managing director Martin Talbot said: "The charts have always been there as a popularity poll, as a means of identifying what are the hottest records of the moment.

"That's been relatively simple when people have bought stuff to keep forever. But that's going to become increasingly more complicated."

He added: "Knowing what a stream is worth compared to a purchase of a download, for instance, is very difficult to identify at the moment, but that's obviously going to be the next step."

The Official Charts Company recently announced the relaunch of the UK's Official Independent Charts.

13. Robin T -
The singles charts are bad enough as it is without including airplay or streamed tracks.

What next, including ringtones and phone videos? At number five in this week's Top 40 is 'Party Boy' from Jackass, at four is a comedy clip from Michael McIntyre, three is Keeley Hazel posing in her pants to a generic techno track, number two is the Eastenders Theme performed by Crazy Frog and number one is Jack Bower's phone ringing in 24.

Plus, it would be very easy for record labels to cheat, or for an internet campaign to spring up and propel anything into the charts. Even if it's limited to one play per computer, people in schools or universities could log in with multiple computers so their streams are counted multiple times.

It's never going to happen, but I'd like to see a chart where each sale is multiplied by the number of tracks the person buys in a year. That would clear out all the Flop Idols and mean the chart is dominated by real acts.

14. Robin T -
Anyone else on the list going to Glastonbury? We could have a Chart Watch meet up if that doesn't sound too sad!

15. Tim -
Hi James and everyone else!
This is my first comment although I've been checking the UK Charts and this commentary since many many years! I love it, thanks so much!!
I am from Germany and I have to say the German Charts are really boring. A few years ago we've had new singles in the Top 10 quite often, but with the new download era it all became dull ("Poker face" is at No. 1 for a 12th week now!). I find it interesting though that the UK Charts itself also changed a bit! I remember the good old charts around the start of the decade with 5 or more new entries in the top 10! I loved that. And now the Billboard Top 10 almost go that pattern... at least one has to say that they lightened up a bit, given that they were so constant and boring a few years ago.
Oh and another thing: someone noted a few weeks ago that Alizée's "Moi... Lolita" was the last fully foreign language song in the UK Top 10! How strange is that... OK, I'm from Germany, but I am used to songs not in my mother language! Apart from UK and America I think almost everyone is! And yes, we do not understand every song or the lyrics by the first listen. 8 out of 10 English speaking songs in the German Top 10 is common, I think! But well, on the other side it makes it a bit more international...
Well, thanks again James for your entertainment and information every week! Keep it up!!

16. Ricardo -
Well, where to start?

@Matt - Billboard already has it covered since 1991: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_100_Singles_Recurrents#Recurrents

@Malcolm - It's not just subjective opinion that drives stations to add/keep a song on their playlists. There is also listener request data and a thing called callout research.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hook_(music)#Use_in_market_research

@Robin T - The kind of chart you envision will only be possible in a world population of 1.

17. CJ -
Finally, a dance song at number one, see what happens when its played on the radio unlike other dance songs.

The day airplay becomes part of the chart will be the day I stop listening, I mean thats absolutely ridiculous.

I cant be bothered to say anything else.

18. Christoph -
@ This charming man:
I was able for the first time yesterday to enter the BBC-stream (I´m from Germany) and heard about an hour of the chart show (from 13-1). Growing up in the 80´s and listening to BFBS (British Forces Broadcasting Services) gave me a good insight how a chart-show should be like. Names like Charles Foster or Paul Gambaccini (there were more, but I can´t remember the names) recall memories of pleasure listening to the shows. I even got up at 4 a.m. on saturdays to listen to them. I won´t judge from listening to just one show I heard from R & F, but the whole discussion in the last few months make me believe that their show isn´t getting better ...

19. Yahoo! Music User -
Excuse me for being dumb, but I thought the sales chart was there to show who's making the most money and not the biggest ego's on the planet. Radio airplay started in the USA because it wasn't possible physcial to collect data from record stores all over the USA. It worked when first introduced because most people who purchased records did so after a few plays on the radio and they did that because the radio and gramphone player were the only thing in the house for entertaiment. These days it's plain stupid to use this format at all.
Spotify and We7 are just libaries of tracks to record and store in your own collection. When the record companies work that out they will be making users pay and then they will go down the pan and something new will replace this way of getting music at low cost. They (Spotify and We7) are no different to FM radio, the top 40 and a cassette recorder. Who remembers the blank tape levy idea the music industry came up to stop that.
This all comes about with having the OCC providing the only charts. There's just no competion!

Following the demise of Hit40Uk on radio, it is still in operation though. Only it seems it's on 4Music TV channel, weird!

20. Iain -
I was surprised at Little Boots' big drop on the album chart. Perhaps just the victim of the Father's Day rush but at the moment, she is not even close to matching the success Duffy enjoyed last year. 'New in Town' is a very disappointing lead from the album.

Is George Harrison's no.4 album really that much of a surprise, James? The record company is cashing in on Father's day and it was only a couple of years ago that the Travelling Wilburys scored a massive album around the same time of year.

I agree with those saying that airplay should not be included in the chart. But this is not what is being muted by the OCC. Streaming MAY eventually become the method of choice for listening to music and as such the OCC have no choice but to include this in its chart. The fact that the OCC have made public the possibility of including 'streamed' tracks, shows that they are forward thinking and keen to ensure the chart correctly reflects the popularity of music in the country. I don't think ringtones or radio airplay will ever be included.

Incidentally, James mentions at the end of his commentary that sales of digital tracks are rising. I would suggest that sales of LEGAL digital tracks are rising. Some may be more wary of using file sharing sites, given recent press coverage!
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jedward eye future

Dotmusic -
Mon 23 Nov 2009 4:46PM GMT

Dotmusic - Duo 'aren't gutted' after X Factor axe More »

More News Stories