Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending October 31st 2009

Posted Mon 26 Oct 2009 1:07PM GMT by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

Call me a fantasist if you will, but I can't help but note a theme developing here. Just as last week the two biggest new singles of the week both had a performance by their respective stars on the X Factor Results show in common, so too the most significant chart moves of the week are inextricably linked to the all-conquering TV talent show. In a sense it is actually quite scary to watch.

Most singles which had stormed to the top with a sale in excess of six figures could be expected to hang on for another couple of weeks at least whilst the rest of the market caught up. Not so 'Bad Boys' by Alexandra Burke which slips down to Number 2 this week. Replacing her at the top is the very lady who we are led to believe "mentored" here during the X Factor competition last year - Cheryl Cole. Her first ever solo single 'Fight For This Love' was the focal point of the results show last weekend and with such public attention lavished on it, the single could hardly fail. Nonetheless there were more than a few jaws dropping open on Tuesday lunchtime when the early sales for the single came in. Over the course of just two days, 'Fight For This Love' had shifted a whopping 130,000 copies - just 50,000 short of the total notched up by Alexandra Burke for the entire week. This had crossed the line from single into absolute utter phenomenon.

The transformation of Cheryl Cole from nervous talent show entrant to suave superstar has been pretty impressive in itself. As Cheryl Tweedy she was one of the five unknowns selected by the very same Saturday night TV audience to form Girls Aloud. Never the strongest singer of the bunch, she somehow managed to command one of the highest public profiles, even if the infamous 2003 nightclub toilet incident meant that it wasn't quite for the best reasons. Clues that she was being primed for her own career away from the group came last year when a guest vocal from her was added to the single version of 'Heartbreaker' by will.i.am last year. With Girls Aloud now "on hiatus" for a bit, it is time for Cheryl to stand alone in the spotlight. Much was made in the build-up to her solo TV debut last weekend over whether she would sing live or not, the weakness of her voice something the people around her are only too aware of it seems. In the event the performance of 'Fight For This Love' was a tightly choreographed show-stopper and it is almost certainly this exposure that has helped what would otherwise be a rather lightweight pop-dance number to the top of the charts with best of the year so far sale.

That sales total in full? A massive 290,000 copies, the best single week sale by any single this year and a total which extraordinarily manages to beat the first week sales total of the debut Girls Aloud single 'Sound Of The Underground' from December 2002. You could be forgiven for predicting she too would be there for the long run, but for the fact she may well face competition from - you guessed it - the act performing as I write this on this week's X Factor Results show.

So who was it who followed Cheryl onstage on TV last week? Well none other than Whitney Houston, superstar mentor for the week to the final 11 contestants, with the added bonus that she was able to plug the long-delayed UK release of her comeback album. Thanks to that performance its lead single 'Million Dollar Bill' finally takes off. After two weeks on the chart lingering outside the Top 10,the single finally puts on a sales spurt and rockets 14-5, at a stroke becoming her biggest chart hit since 'My Love Is Your Love' was a Number 2 hit in July 1999. In total it is the 13th Top 5 hit of a chart career that dates back to late 1985.

 

If the singles chart is dominated by reality TV shows, then the album chart is at least dominated by some massive new releases, although the dreaded "X" expression isn't far behind any of them. Providing her with some consolation for such a brief reign at Number One, Alexandra Burke storms to the top with her debut album 'Overcome'. Whitney Houston, in spite of the gratuitous plugs for her album on the TV show, has to content herself with a Number 3 entry for 'I Look To You'. It is a dramatic turnaround from the rather disastrous performance of her last studio album, the largely ignored 'Just Whitney' failing to chart at all in this country. Although her 2000 'Greatest Hits' release topped the charts, it is interesting to note that she has only once topped the UK charts with an album of original studio material - 1987 release 'Whitney' and home of the Number One single 'I Wanna Dance With Somebody'.

The Number 2 album I hear you ask? 'Crazy Love' by Michael Buble which thus matches the peak of his 2007 album 'Call Me Irresponsible'. Its lead single 'Haven't Met You Yet' stays firm at Number 9 on the singles chart this week, the prospects of both formats boosted immeasurably by his performing presence on national television at the weekend. I'll leave it as a quick mental exercise for you to work out which one that is.

Back to singles and the second highest new entry of the week lands at Number 10 for the charity collective known as the Young Soul Rebels. 'I Got Soul' is released in aid of the War Child UK charity and features a host of British acts ranging from N-Dubz and Tinchy Stryder through to Chipmunk, Ironik, Frankmusic and Pixie Lott. It is based heavily on the 2005 Killers track 'All These Things I've Done', using the line "I got soul, but I'm not a soldier" to draw attention to the plight of the thousands of child soldiers worldwide. Like most charity singles it kind of defies critical analysis, but ranks as one of the more credible ensemble offerings you are likely to hear over the next few weeks, make no mistake about that.

 

Once place behind at Number 11 is 'Meet Me Halfway' from the Black Eyed Peas which as we speculated in the podcast is not so much meeting their last hit on the way down but charging up to join it. Just as 'I Gotta Feeling' charted contemporaneously with 'Boom Boom Pow', so their third hit of the year is racing up the charts as its predecessor just refuses to go away. Former Number One 'I Gotta Feeling' has yet to fall out of the Top 10 and slips just one place to Number 7 this week. Place your bets on whether they will cross-over or sit side by side next week.

New at Number 17 is 'Good Girls Go Bad' from Cobra Starship. It is the first UK chart hit for the American pop-rock group and is taken from their third album 'Hot Mess'. Already a Top 10 smash hit in America, the single features a guest contribution from Gossip Girl star Leighton Meester as if to further cement its place in popular culture. You may not be familiar with the group themselves but their previous work may not have escaped your attention, as it was their song 'Snakes On A Plane (Bring It)' which played out over the closing credits of the cult movie of the same name.

Pop fans the nation over will welcome the return of Alphabeat with their brand new single 'The Spell' at Number 20 although once again the chart placing of the single does reflect the struggle the Danish group have in gaining a proper commercial foothold in this country. The problem isn't the music itself, as every single Alphabeat record to date has been a mini masterpiece of unashamed pop music as the group act as a grand throwback to the FM radio sound of the 1980s. The problem is that their breezy cheerfulness sits somewhat uncomfortably with the more cynical sound of the current age. I listen to their music and find myself liking it but at the same time just cannot work out why I should find it, well, relevant really. Debut single 'Fascination' (as performed on X Factor at the weekend by the final 10) remains their only Top 10 hit to date, a Number 6 hit from February 2008. Follow-up singles 'Ten Thousand Nights' and 'Boyfriend' were just as good but struggled to Top 20 placings and on first impressions this brand new single is destined to go the same way. Check it out for yourselves and make up your own minds. Alphabeat are very very good, but have yet to find a way to make people actually care.

One act with few such credibility issues are the Foo Fighters who as a group now enter their 14th year of hitmaking with their 16th Top 30 hit single 'Wheels'. Their first chart single since December 2007, the track is a token new release from a forthcoming Greatest Hits collection to be released at the start of November. 'Wheels' is at a stroke their biggest hit single since 'The Pretender' charted at Number 8 in August 2007.

Finally this week we need to note the traditional surge in support for older songs as performed by X Factor contestants. Leading the charge this week is 'Hurt' by Christina Aguilera which rockets to Number 25 following the "divas week" performance by Jamie Archer. Originally a Number 11 hit for the star in November 2006, this is oddly enough the second time the track has been propelled back into the charts thanks to a TV performance. Two years ago girl group Hope performed it live on the show, sending the single back into the Top 40 for the first time since its release. The most gratuitous product placement of the week however had to be Danyl Johnson's performance of 'I Didn't Know My Own Strength', a hitherto unnoticed and at the time unknown track from the new Whitney Houston album. The track naturally becomes the cherrypickers selection of choice this week and it results in the song resting at Number 44. With last weekend's swing theme restricting contestants to rather older works, the X Factor effect may be slightly less pronounced next week, although if we see a surge for 'Angel Of Harlem' don't say I didn't warn you.

33 Comments

1. David -
The success of songs featured on the x factor, sometimes even a contestant singing an old song will boost its chart placing, should surely wake the BBC up to bringing back TOTP, as there are so few outlets for music on mainstream shows

2. D -
Cheryl Cole has become a phenomenon- the nations sweetheart. I don't dislike her, she looks amazing and has cleverly used the XFactor to turn herself into a household name- a 'brand' that could become bigger than Beckham. She looks sophisticated but manages to retain the girl next door charm that many young girls can connect with and she still appears obtainable to many young lads- unlike Posh. I still remember watching poor Cheryl struggle to read an article about Girl's Aloud printed in the Sun (designed with the reading age of an average 10 year old in mind) on tv when the band was first launched- it was embarrassing!
The domination of albums and singles chart by XFactor continues to grow- at least a dozen acts owe there position on the chart to appearance or use in the show. Glad Whitney has gone top 5 with her retro dance track- even if her performance was disappointing. Interesting to see what happens to Michael Buble who gave by far the most polished and professional performance of all guest acts to appear so far- will his version of Cry Me A River now chart along with Haven't Met You Yet? Didn't Westlife look old - Shane could do with some of Louis botox! Such a lame version of a lame track too. Alexandra has a number of tracks appearing on the 100- similar to Leona when she released her debut album. Doesn't look like Feelin' Good will be flying up the chart if Danyl's bottom placing is an accurate barometer. JLS & Bon Jovi next week- interesting to see what happens to Bon Jovi's back catalogue as a result.
liking the Young Soul Rebels track & BEPs can do no wrong- I didn't get the first 2 hits at the start but have to admit they really are great tracks!- as is Taio Cruz who I also slated! Good to see the wet cover of Shirelles Mama Said by Dionne Bromfield dropping- she really is nothing special- goes to show it helps to have connections! Lady GaGa's domination has subsided- temporarily. Low disappointing entry at 82 for Spandau Ballet. Is it only me or is anyone else disturbed at the fact a pretty female would appear to have taken her 'stage' name from a sadistic Roman Emperor- I am of course referring to Little Boots! Dame Shirley Bassey was awesome on BBC Electric Proms- SHE IS 72! Saturdays album dropping like a stone- as is Madonna- I kinda feel that Madge has reached a bit of a tipping point in her career- too old to continue with her current style- in danger of looking like bad drag!- I am a Madonna fan btw! Her career needs careful consideration over next 18 months- but her best work is almost certainly behind her. Love Jay-Z and Alicia Keys luv it luv it luv it! Hope Robbies album fails to hit No1- best X(Factor)Mas present ever!

3. D -
David, the reason BBC dropped TOTPs is because no one was watching it- the format was dead.
It used to be required viewing- often the only chance you got to see the artists perform- my heart used to sink when Pan's People would shimmy their way through some excellent US track cos the artist were Stateside or unable to appear due to Musicians Union ( a big problem back in the day- if an American artist appeared on TV here- then a UK artist had to appear on US TV 'tit for tat'- meant many US artists missed the chance to promote their latest release even though they were here visiting UK) Thanks to youtube I am at last able to view for the first time brilliant performaces from soul train and other us shows that we in the uk were denied.

4. egor -
It is so irritating when some X Factor idiot performs a song and it enters the chart. This week it's Aguilera. The chart rules nowadays are absolutely ridiculous. But there's some good news for everyone who has good taste in music - Madonna's album has plummeted to number 14. I think soon her singles will struggle to get to Top 10. She is the most overhyped artist of all time, her only talent is ability to promote herself. Unfortunately, no talent in music.

5. Yahoo! Music User -
Westlife are still awesome.

How come 'She Bangs' is not leaping up the chart? Maybe cause She-Bombed.

6. graham -
James you look like being wrong on Angel of Harlem being big next week. I checked I-Tunes & Amazon, Saturday night, Sunday morning and both today (Monday). Normally there's plenty of movement of X-Factor songs sung by the acts allready making inroads into those listings. But not this week. In fact 'none' to be on the nail. Only on a Monday did that U2 song appear at 92 on the Tunes.
Perhaps it was due in part to the fact that these 'old tracks' are not available to download. Or perhaps the younger downloaders were not interested in buying Frank Sinatra?
I will tell you one thing if the phone voters keep that up Cowell will pull the plug on the show. It just goes to prove you can't predict the X-Factor results from download sales.

What the hell was Reg doing on the chart show? It overrun by nearly 5 minutes.

We keep going around in circles with TOTP. There's a book on it and it clearly states that Andy Peters was responsible for killing the show. That combined with a singles chart that those watching could not effect, because of the new entries each week. I went to look at the BBC Points of View website the other week to see if I could post something asking the BBC to commission a weekly show that catered for the download market, pointing out that they were ignoring a large section of the viewing public. But it was that complex and diffcult to register (they wanted a lot of personal details) for what would be perhaps my only comment, that I gave up!
If someone else wants a go please feel free to mention what I said. Warning don't mention TOTP as the controller stated that it will not be re-commissioned. I think they will ignore any request for that show to be brought back in full and any other type of show if you do. They can be petty down at Beebland.

7. Yahoo! Music User -
Post 2 - You are hardly one to criticise Cheryl Cole's reading abilities with some of your poor grammar, particularly with apostrophes; e.g. "nations sweetheart", "Girl's Aloud", "Louis", "Robbies". Also, "there position" should be "their position".

8. Damian -
Early signs are that Cheryl will hold onto the number one spot, westlife number 2 and jay sean number 3 this week. Don't be surprised, those massive sales last week are unlikely to massively drop.. not sure on average what westlife tend to get with there first new releases but I doubt there fanbase is large enough to hold off Cheryl..also the Westlife track is very poor I have to say I'd much rather Draughtry re-enter the chart.

Back to the charts this week, pleased to see Alphabeat enter the top 20, shame they are no higher than number 20. Also good to see the foo fighters in the charts again - a credible act in a sea of flash in the pan/ flavour of the month acts such as tinchy strider, chipmunk, taio cruz.. (the list could go on..).

9. D -
post 8- i am like most people- less particular when communincating by e-mail- which is much more relaxed form of communication- to hell with convention- but my spoken english and formal writing is [profane] hot- hence my BA(Hons)1st class - big rasberry blowing in your direction!

10. Robin T -
I was interested to see that Alan McGee reckons that streaming will overtake downloads in the future. Not on the bus it won't!

Does anyone know if Napster still offers the unlimited download subscription service, as I notice they have just launched a new streaming service?

11. Robin T -
Good to see Cascada drop out of the chart after just one week with 'Dangerous'.

Their new single was awful, but so were all their previous ones.

Several people in the past have called Cascada fans 'chavs' or 'neds' so I thought I'd explain why I agree.

No-one who listens to all the new releases decides that out of all the songs they have heard Cascada are best. Only lazy people who like what they are told to like or buy music that sounds like what they hear in a club buy it. They only buy the well-promoted singles and not the other ones, because they are just following a trend. Rather like wearing a knock-off Burbury cap because all their idiot friends do.

I am a big fan of proper dance music, but not this reconstituted vomit.

12. Robin T -
I heard of Cobra Starship not through the new single or Snakes on a Plane but singer Gabe Saporta's appearance on the MC Lars track "Hey There Ophelia" (which also features Brett Anderson of the Donnas.

The song is a rap based on Hamlet, but pinches the chorus from the 1993 top ten hit 'Screamager' by Therapy?

It might be a novelty track (does MC Lars make anything else?), but it's worth a listen.

13. Darrin -
I like Cascadas last song strange that they'd go from no.1 hit to a top70 flop. I think "Meet me halfway" is better than their last two songs it'll probably jump over "I gotta feeling" next week.

14. Rob -
Good to see Alphabeat back in the charts although a top 20 scraping is a little worrying. I'm still miffed that the last single off the first album 'What is happening' spectacularly flopped and only got to #110. I know it was law of diminishing returns and xmas rush,... but seriously 110?!!

I know I brought her up last week, but it would be interesting to see how Dannii Minogue would have fared had she been in Cheryls position. The good lady is re-releasing her first two albums and getting an entire unreleased 1995 album coming out in november. Woner if she will be allowed to perform anything from it. Ditto Sinitta with her greatest hits!!! I'd be all up for Sinitta prancing around on the stage in her palm leaves.

Good riddance to Cascada flopping. Their last single was a good pop tune but Dangerous was rehashed crap which gives dance music a bad name- ditto Basshunter. Shame that even with Radio 1 playlisting, Tiesto and Sneaky Sound System stalled in the mid forties.

Chicane new in at 42- is the single download only? If so sad that this will be its peak, though Chicane has never been that consistent with chart placings. Give him three years and he will be back in the top 10 again...

15. a1 -
where the hell is natalie imbruglia's single?
now that is pure class!!!
www.a1charts.blogspot.com

16. Michael -
why isnt westlife's new single "what about now" in the top 75? its an awesome single

gooo westlife

17. James -
Post 16 with regard to Natalie Imbruglia - Want it was released on September 28th and reached no. 88 in the UK but faired better elsewhere http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Want_(Natalie_Imbruglia_song)

disappointing as it like all her other hits is a good song and rather different from her usual style.

It's a shame that Mr. Hudson - White Lies has slipped i'd have thought that it would have done better with the success of Supernova. Well worth a listen is the no. 64 song that has shot up from no. 111 Miike Snow - Black & Blue the video has the actor who played Reg Hollis in The Bill but he has a massive wig and hair so you'd hardly recognize him.

18. Rik -
Totally agree with post 18 - Miike Snow 'Black & Blue' is best song in top 75 and deserves to be a lot higher but in these times of R&B fodder, X-Factor rubbish etc it is unlikely too. But for true music fans who read this post check it out together with their excellent album too, my second favourite this year only to the outstanding debut album by The XX .... but that's another story!!

19. karl -
if you're all tired of the x-factor trash that keeps cluttering the tv and radio do something about it, dont debate it, dont watch it. it only lines the pockets of those on the panel, it doesnt do anything for the music industry as such it gives false hope and shattered dreams to every karaoke singer in the country.
so to that end, jump back on myspace and find your new band, give them your time and energy, go out into your local area and listen to the bands out there who are trying to break through, good or bad atleast they're out there doing it and not pinning their hopes on an exhausted talent show.
if you want to listen to something good an honest have a listen to this band. you will be glad you did. this band deserves the support and attention of a thousand wannabe x-factor finalists. they write their own songs and play their instruments and the singer can really sing, no auto tune insight, so give them a listen.
www.myspace.com/sonnermusic
Timechanger was released on monday october 19th.
the video can be seen on you tube type sonner music video timechanger.
thanks.

20. egor -
I agree about Black And Blue too. A great song!
Page:  1 | 2 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jedward eye future

Dotmusic -
Mon 23 Nov 2009 4:46PM GMT

Dotmusic - Duo 'aren't gutted' after X Factor axe More »

More News Stories