Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending August 30th 2008

Posted Mon 25 Aug 2008 9:57AM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

Top of the charts? Nothing happening here really. Singles wise it is Katy Perry who once again takes top honours with 'I Kissed A Girl' comfortably clocking up a third week as the best selling single in the country. She is now the first solo American female to spend more than a fortnight at the top since Madonna's three week run with 'Hung Up' in late 2005 - hits from Rihanna and Madonna's own '4 Minutes' have had longer runs at the top since of course but both their singles also had equally credited male guest stars and so technically weren't "solo" singles.

Once place behind Katy are The Script who ease their way to a new peak of Number 2 with 'The Man Who Can't Be Moved', the continuing success of the single corresponding to the continuing success of their self-titled album which remains supreme at the head of a static Top 4 on the albums chart. The monotony is broken by the arrival at Number 5 of 'Monkey - Journey To The West', the musical concept album from Damon Albarn and Jamie Hewlett which forms the score of the acclaimed stage adaptation of the famous Chinese novel of the same name. Its chart arrival neatly coincides with the use of the music as the theme to the BBC's TV coverage of the just concluded Beijing Olympics.

What is theoretically the most notable single release of the week is through a now well known technicality absent from the charts. The promotion for the forthcoming Oasis album 'Dig Out Your Soul' (released on October 5th) began this week with pre-orders being made available on iTunes. As seems to be the fashion, the pre-orders came with an "instant gratification" promotion which saw copies of Track 7 'Falling Down' made available to purchasers as a taster. Although also available as a single download, its bundling as part of the album purchase disqualifies it from the chart - the same fate of course that befell 'Viva La Vida' a couple of months ago. This bar won't be lifted for another month when the full album is made available, so the first chart impact of the new album will actually be the official lead single 'The Shock Of The Lightning' which will hit stores on September 29. It already has a video, so why not take a listen now.

So what is the biggest new hit of the week? Well that honour goes to Scottish rockers Biffy Clyro whose career reaches a whole new peak as brand new single 'Mountains' lands at Number 10 to give them their first ever Top 10 hit after six years of trying. Its popularity can be explained by its status as a true standalone single. Theoretically it will be one of the tracks on their forthcoming fifth album but with no release scheduled until next year at the earliest, 'Mountains' represents the only chance for fans of the band to get their hands on brand new material. I know I said in the Podcast last week that physical release dates were now so irrelevant I wasn't going to pay much attention to them any more, but it is still worth noting that a physical version of 'Mountains' hits the shops this week which should help to sustain its Top 10 status for at least one more week.

Also new, albeit in a rather more understated manner than some fans were hoping is 'Steve McQueen', the brand new offering from The Automatic. The sparkling new single represents their return after a self-imposed hiatus to integrate new member Paul Mullen, the group keen not to make him a direct replacement for keyboardist Alex Pennie who left the band last year. In truth their main problem is not a change of personnel but the need to escape the shadow of breakthrough hit 'Monster' which made such an impact in the summer of 2006 that they have struggled ever since to follow it up adequately. Just for a change then, the two year break between albums may actually have done them a favour and we can hear their new material with fresh ears and hopefully without the need to refer back to that earlier hit.

So here is one fresh perspective - 'Steve McQueen' is a quite inspiring comeback, a statement of intent from a group sounding refreshed, renewed but one which keeps intact the thundering gothic basslines that made their earlier work so instantly addictive. People had their fingers crossed for a Top 10 debut but its actual entry point of Number 16 will do for now - particularly as the track does indeed become their biggest hit single since The One We Shall No Longer Name.

Heading upwards with some vigour is 'She's Like A Star', the latest track from Taio Cruz which vaults 32-20 (and yes, OK, that can also be put down to its CD release last week). The track is his third Top 20 hit of the year, the successor to 'I Can Be' which hit Number 18 in the wake of 'Come On Girl' which made Number 5. Intriguingly whilst the track is available in a remixed version which features both Busta Rhymes and The Sugababes, it is the original album version which appears to be the most popular and even more strangely it is this, rather than the remix, which features on the just released CD.

At least Cruz hasn't had to compete with himself for follow-up hits. This is on the other hand the rather large problem faced by Gabriella Cilmi who is brand new at Number 33 with new single 'Save The Lies (Good To Me)'. Her challenge (and that of her label) is getting people to notice it as its predecessor 'Sweet About Me' shows no sign of burning out, this week marching back up three places to rest at Number 15 in what is now its 24th week on the singles chart. As addictive as her first hit was, it is this release that shows what the Australian teenager is capable of, an intoxicating uptempo pop single of the kind some of us have been longing to hear all year.

The risk of the summers mega hits eclipsing their successors has already claimed one victim in the shape of Sam Sparro whose second single '21st Century Life' effectively bombed at Number 44 a couple of weeks ago, going almost unnoticed as radio and the public at large are still enchanted by 'Black And Gold' which ranks at Number 28 this week, having first appeared in the same week as 'Sweet About Me'. It is an issue which A&R departments at major labels are having to wrestle with carefully. Multiple singles from an artist help to stimulate album sales and keep them in the public eye, but promotional activities have to be carefully scheduled to dovetail with the availability of their acts and available slots on TV and in the press etc. In the old days it was simple, you just ran down stocks or even deleted an older hit to remove it from the shops and thus the charts. That of course is just no longer possible. Singles cannot be pushed back indefinitely but if an earlier hit refuses to stop selling, there seems very little anyone can do.

Finally this week the chart welcomes the return of Metallica with their first single release in four and a half years. New single 'The Day That Never Comes' was only made available online last Saturday and so charts at Number 36 on the strength of one days sales - suggesting a huge flying leap up the chart will result in seven days time. Their appearance at the Leeds festival last week has also prompted a surge of interest in their back catalogue and in particular tracks from their 1991 album 'Metallica' which represented their historical commercial peak. Hence the reappearance for the first time in 16 years of 'Nothing Else Matters' at Number 53 (original peak: Number 6 in May 1992) and 'Enter Sandman' at Number 60 (original peak: Number 5 in August 1991). Their last Top 10 hit came back in 2003 when 'St Anger' made Number 9 - place your bets on 'The Day That Never Comes' making an assault on a similar placing next week.

64 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
Regarding the issue of chart-ineligible singles: In cases where a song is given away for free to album buyers but can also be purchased separately as a single download, I would suggest to allow that song to chart but only count the sales derived from the downloads of the single. Surely it is technically possible to differentiate between downloads of the single and the giveaway copies?

2. James -
I can't believe that its taking so long for "Sweet About Me," "Black & Gold," "Closer," "Low" "Forever," etc too fall off the chart. They have all been out for months, and yet one minute they start falling and then suddenly to my annoyance they move back up again. Three of the songs i mentioned have been out since March/April and its almost September! and yet "Sweet About Me'" and "Black & Gold," are bouncing around the top 30! Plus Flo Rida is now promoting a new single "In The Ayer," and Low still seems to be sellling strongly. Seriously its amazing how after months everyone still likes the song. One reason why the charts are becoming boring...In my opinion the slowest descent is "Closer," it seems to be falling down one place each week, which is still amazing because it had already reached the Top 10 WAY ahead of proper release...and now its at No.12. And i've been eagerly awaiting for Chris Browns "Forever," to fall down the chart quickly to make room for "Kiss Kiss," but its bouncing up and down the upper end of the top 30! :(
Has there actually been a Physical release of "Spiralling" by Keane? if so i think the single should have at least gone top 20. Its grow on me abit...:)

3. Yahoo! Music User -
I think the new Fratellis song is great. Certainly the strongest new entry of the week. Is there any chance for it to rise from #70?

4. dcs234 -
We are still very much in a period of transition between the old charts and these new-fangled ones. I don't have a solution for flushing tired old hits off the charts if they are still outselling newer ones and it's possible that there is no fair solution. Nevertheless, it's clear that while the singles market has been given a boost by the introduction of digital sales into the reckoning there is still some way to go to create a chart which truly reflects the record buying habits of the nation.

In the US, Billboard manages to resolve this somehow so that you don't see Lynyrd Skynyrd charting 40 places below Kid Rock, but they also suffer from a fair amount of stagnation with songs regularly staying in the top 10 for months at a time.

My question is whether there is some kind of review committee constantly looking for ways to improve the charts and what are their objectives and metrics for success?

5. Martin -
Rihanna's from Barbados...

6. Yahoo! Music User -
Bardados, being a group of islands in the Caribbean, belongs to America, doesn't it? James was speaking of "artists from America" as opposed to "artists from the United States". So he was correct.

7. Yahoo! Music User -
I think that the chart must be badly affected this week as the HMV downloads has been down due to a fault. It's still off as of Monday!
On the slow chart, it is clearly down to not enough outlets for download and the silly restrictions put on who can sell what. Take Amazon UK why doesn't that have downloads. The US one does. Why do online shops only seem to sell one file format?
HMV and others have complained that the market is not open enough, they also want a better chart.
DRM seems to be the biggest problem. (if you want to get round this by the way, after you download, play the file back and use an audio recording software (IE) Easy Audio Editor, recording wave out. The 'new' file is free of it.
DRM is being removed from September on HMV, maybe why it's down?

8. Regino -
That's the problem concerning dusters like Black and Gold and others. It would be best to release latest ones when sales are lower, song in about top 50 or 60 but still more people are buying it. I suggest don't promote something selling too long.
For example, adverts like 'the sofa advert that has the song Rockstar in it'.
Speaking of that, Rockstar needs to get out! It's over 7-9 months this song, goodness.

9. CRAIG -
I don't mind the long-runners in the chart. I think it gives a much fairer and much more accurate view of what people are buying. I hated it when record companies could simply manipulate the charts by deleteing a single when they had something else to promote. I especially like that Lynyrd Skynyrd can re-enter the chart (after all, people are buying the song) and it's GREAT to see Metallica back.

On a similar note, perhaps James (or someone) could tell me if Barry Manilow's Can't Smile Without You is anywhere near re-entering the chart after it's extensive use in the new Hellboy film which opened on Friday last week...? I'd love to see Bazza back in the chart before he comes over here for his concerts in December!

10. Yahoo! Music User -
James how come you have made no reference to the continual rise of Rhianna's Disturbia?! As a reader of your column for the past 2 years it has become blatantly obvious to me that you don't particularily care for her as an artist! So what if she has releashed a few singles off the 1 album, IT'S NO BIG DEAL! If her tracks off Good Girl Gone Bad continue to soar up the charts release after release then why shouldn't she continue to bank in on the album's success? And it's not like she's the first ever artist to re-release a popular album with a few new tracks. There is no doubt that she's the world's most powerful artist at the minute. She's the music megastar of the noughties and people are just begrudging her success because she has the ability to follow huge number 1s like Take A Bow with another top 5 hit

11. Yahoo! Music User -
I think record companies should be allowed to delete their artist's records digitally if they so wish. Tracks hanging round the charts for several months destroys the artist's chance of a successful follow up. Just look at Gabriella Cilmi, Sweet About Me at #15 after 24 weeks on the chart, which is SIX months. If Sweet About Me was deleted from the chart, record stations and music video stations would start promoting Save The Lies and could potentially send the record flying up the chart, much higher than 33 anyways . . After it took her so long to make Sweet About Me a successful top 10 hit, it must be devastating to see her 2nd single bomb. The only other alternative would be to wait until Sweet About Me was outside the top 40, but then again they could be waiting another 3 or 4 months easily before that happens.

I'm delighted to see Colbie Caillat's Bubbly finally cracking the top 75. It's a brill track and I cant believed it flopped the first time round. I mean this is a track that topped the Australian Chart and reached #5 in the US. At #65 this week and not due for a full release until Sept 8th hopefully it can finally become a mainstream hit in the UK and enjoy the commercial success it deserves! Also climbing the chart this week is Duffy's Stepping Stone, up 18 places to #62. With 2 more weeks to go until a full release it will be interesting to see if it can go top 10. Frankly I wouldn't be surprised if i only managed top 20, because of the amazing sales of Rockferry. After all it is 2008's biggest seller so far . .

Disappointing to see that Ida Maria falls to 18 this week, after reaching a new peak of 13 this week I thought it could finally crack the top 10 this week. If she releashed this in June or July, pre the Katy Perry era, I'm sure it would have shot up the top 10. Their music has a very similar style.

Delighted with the success of The Script in the UK! It's about time us Irish had a new successful act in the British charts. And contrary to reports, they're from DUBLIN, not NORTHERN IRELAND. Typical though that ye'd try and claim them. They must be the first new Irish act to hit the UK Top 10 since the hey days of Samantha Mumba & Westlife. They're definitely here to stay . .

12. Yahoo! Music User -
I think it's funny - I mean people complaining of the slow pace of the chart nowadays. I remember back in the 90s people used to complain that the chart was moving way too fast! I think every person's view depens on what he or she grew up upon and got used to. People in the 90s could remember that the 70s and 80s saw comparatively slow turnovers and hence they were appalled by songs entering high and disappearing again two weeks later. In 2008, people remember the fast moving 90s and think that this was the way the charts "should" be, and so they complain of the lack of high entries and short lived hits. In my opinion, there is nothing to complain about - and nothing to "do" about it. If old songs are what the public is buying, so be it. And as long as they are bought in large quantities, those old songs deserve a place in the charts. Why manipulate the chart by artificially by "removing" songs after a given time like the Americand do? Let's be thankful that we have the most accurate chart in the world and a true barometer of what the people are buying. If the new Cilmi single doesn't sell, don't blame the charts.

13. Yahoo! Music User -
I didnt want to post anonymously, but somehow Yahoo didnt accept my nick on post #11 above. michael_787

14. Yahoo! Music User -
sorry I meant post #12, but in the meantime Yahoo rectified it.

15. Padraig S -
The new Metallica track is excellent and deserves to go Top 10. Any sign of Kings of Leon's new single in the charts? Slipknot amazingly have been knocking around the lower end of the Top 75 for the past month... cant see it breaking the Top 40 unfortunately, it needs a good old shakeup.

16. James -
Yahoo! Music User!
Of course James doesn't care about Rihanna. Who does? I think James would rather care about real music :) Besides, Rihannas chart performances are just predictable now. Another random track off her album which scores at the most top 15. I think James would get bored of writing about 10 (ok an exaggeration) Rihanna tracks from one album. As much as i can't stand her or her music, i think shes successful enough without having to release all of these singles off one album. Yes, woopdeedoo she can get lots of top 5 followups but its unfair that all these singles aren't giving other artists a chance to maybe reach her level of success. The charts are open to all artists, not just hher, the music industry is not dependent on one artist...Finally even as a fan of Rihanna you have to admit the Disturbia video is a bit...erm creepy

17. Mark -
I was listening to an old Cathy Dennis song today from her 1997 album, which seems to be the fore-runner of I Kissed A Girl, with lyrics such as 'I bet I could be your boyfriend' or something like that. She wrote it with Andy Partrdige from XTC. The album was a bit of a flop but well worth checking else with co-writing with Guy Chambers before he found fame (infamy) with Robbie Williams. I heard Cathy Dennis has returned to recording, but maybe these days the life of a successful writer is more satisfying that that of (one hit) wonders??? But then again Diane Warren was a successful song writer 10 years ago, but seems to have disappeared? My hope that Kylie's 'The One' video would help the signle was obviously well off the mark. By the way, I wonder if yesterday's Olympics concert in London on BBC1 will help sales. Maybe Heather (Foghorn!)Small's Proud will finally give her a big solo hit! Lots of acts seem to be singing new singles e.g. James Morrison and Will Young. Good to see a bit of Sophie Ellis Bextor. What happened to her Greatest Hits??? Interesting that no blockbuster films this Summer have bothered to use a song to accompany the film. This 80/90s trend has all but disappeared. Everything I Do I Do For You! Obviously not anymore!

18. Emyr -
I don't mind seeing songs last over 20 weeks on the chart, but if there is a new song to promote, radio stations should stop playing the previous hit & start playing the new one & if the follow up hit doesn't suit a radio stations playlist they should stop playing the previous one like what's happened with Black & Gold, I still here that on local radio now but no sign of 21st Century Life.

One way of looking at it, it looks good in the record books with all these weeks being clocked up on the charts.

Metallica should go top 10 as it was only released online on Saturday, would be nice if Nothing Else Matters & Enter Sandman re-enter the charts.

19. James Masterton -
For those interested, the cover sheet that comes with the charts each week always notes which chains or stores failed to report on certain days and so have their data from the rest of the week upweighted to compensate.

This week the computer noted missing data from Nokia Music and Napster for Saturday but also that HMV Digital failed to report on Mon, Tue, Thu, Fri and Sat.

20. Theo -
The chart should be a reflection of what people are paying for and not a marketing tool cynically manipulated by the record companies which is what it used to be in the past.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
195
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jay-Z for BRITs

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 11:30AM GMT

Dotmusic - Rap don to perform medley at London bash More »

More News Stories