Music Blogs

RSS Email this page IM this page Bookmark this page

Week Ending May 17th 2008

Posted Sun 11 May 2008 11:08PM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK
With the physical arrival of three highly regarded chart singles, plus the return of one of the most talked about bands of the decade, one could have been forgiven for expecting some kind of change at the top of the singles chart. Sadly it was not to be, although to the cheer of Madonna's legions of fans she grabs a fourth straight week at the summit with '4 Minutes'. The single duly becomes her longest running Number One single since 'Vogue' also had a 28 day residency way back in 1990. In her entire career Madonna has never managed a five week Number One in the UK, a target she stands a good chance of reaching next week.

It also means that we have now had four Number One singles in a row to spend four weeks or more at the the top. As you might expect this is unprecedented in modern chart history and to find the last such occasion you have to travel back as far as 1972 and 1973 when over the seasonal period 'My Ding-A-Ling', 'Long Haired Lover From Liverpool', 'Blockbuster' and 'Cum On Feel The Noize' all had 18 weeks between them at Number One.

As for the three big new physical singles, well in order they are Wiley's 'Wearing My Rolex' which may well have shot its final bolt to reach a new peak of Number 2, will.i.am and Cheryl Cole's 'Heartbreaker' which advances 8-4 (and has by no means peaked yet) and most impressively of all 'In My Arms' from Kylie Minogue which was languishing at Number 46 as a download last week but now soars to Number 10 as a proper full release. The title track and third single from her current album, it extends her decade long run of consecutive Top 10 singles to 16 and is the 32nd such hit of her over 20 year chart career.

The real chart headlines this week will of course not be about any of the above, but will instead focus on the group who debut at Number 8. The release of brand new Coldplay material, their first for three years, would have caused a stir no matter what, but for new track 'Violet Hill' the group have taken an imaginitive approach to marketing. Taking a leaf out of Radiohead's book, the track was made available via their website for free two weeks ago. Anyone wanting to own a copy simply had to log on and click a button with no financial arrangements required. Their label claimed an extraordinary 2 million downloads during the time it was available which like all web statistics has to be taken with a pinch of salt. Nonetheless the truly dedicated had plenty of time to obtain a copy of the track, with those missing the boat needing only to buy this week's NME which cover mounted the seven-inch single.

Despite this mass giveaway, 'Violet Hill' was released online for purchase last week and has duly shifted enough units thanks to those too late or unaware of the free version to register a place in the Top 10. With no physical release scheduled, the track will almost certainly end up as the highest charting download-only single to date, beating out Nelly Furtado's 'Say It Right' which peaked at Number 10 in early 2007. Thanks to this unique form of marketing, Coldplay seem set to continue their curious form of never having had a Number One single in this country, back in 2005 famously seeing 'Speed Of Sound' crash at Number 2 having been unable to shift the damn Crazy Frog from the top.

Perhaps most extraordinarily of all though is the fact that Coldplay could well have charted two singles at once. As well as 'Violet Hill', online purchasers could also obtain a copy of the rather more commercially appealing 'Viva La Vida' which sold enough copies to rank as the 13th biggest seller of the last week. Its absence from the singles chart is due to the group also attemping a marketing scam that is gaining popularity in the States. Purchasers were invited to place a pre-order for their new album (due out as a midweek release on June 12). In doing so they could be billed for the 79p cost of a single track and be given a copy of 'Viva La Vida', the rest of the album following on the day of its release. After a great deal of high level examination of the deal, the Chart Supervisory Committee elected to disqualify the track from the singles chart, ruling that regardless of the price charged to the consumer, its sales were still just a downpayment on the album. Presumably once the pre-order offer is withdrawn the sales of the track will be allowed to count for the chart, but for now it appears that Coldplay have achieved something that was previously thought impossible and made a legally available download track ineligible for the singles chart.

The next notable new chart arrival appears at Number 15. The tradition for football teams playing in the FA Cup Final to record and release a club anthem to celebrate the occasion has more or less died off in recent years, a consequence perhaps of the tournament predictably throwing up the same clubs over and over again in the final. This year however rank outsiders Cardiff City and Portsmouth will play each other this coming weekend at Wembley and so it seems only appropriate that the novelty tradition should be resurrected too. Hence 'Bluebirds Flying High' as performed by James Fox (last seen as Britain's Eurovision entry back in 2004) accompanied by the mass voices of the Cardiff City football team themselves. The team duly become the first FA Cup Finalists to have a chart hit since Millwall FC reached Number 41 with 'Oh Millwall' back in 2004.

One new release which didn't quite make the grade this week was Kelly Rowland's 'Daylight'. A duet with Travis McCoy from Gym Class Heroes, the physical release of the track has helped it to a mere Number 14, enough to surely mean it will become her first single as lead artist to miss the Top 10 since 'Train On A Track' stiffed at Number 20 back in 2003.

Below her there is better news for Duffy who moves up still further, 'Warwick Avenue' advancing 29-17 with physical release still some weeks away. Also new to the Top 20 are Nelly & Fergie whose duet 'Party People' now ranks at Number 19, that single going physical next Monday (May 19).

Destined to be a massive future hit is 'Closer' from Ne-Yo which arrives at Number 22. The first single from forthcoming new album 'Year Of The Gentleman', it arrives on the singles chart after being released to online stores. Don't be fooled by the somewhat low start, airplay and TV exposure for the track has barely begun, its physical release not scheduled until June 30 by which time you can safely expect the track to be Top 3 at the very least.

Following a more conventional release schedule of downloads one week and physical the next are the Pigeon Detectives who land at Number 24 with 'This Is An Emergency'. They too have a new album to promote, their second album 'Emergency' is set for the shops on May 26 and at the very least by this tim next week its lead track should be a Top 20 hit.

Finally for this week I'll leave you with another brand new hit which has been available online for a month already but only now penetrates the Top 40. 'Love Song' from Sara Bareilles has already been a Top 5 hit in America and now seems set to make a similar impact here. June 2 is its projected physical release date, but needless to say by the time that finally arrives the single seems destined to be a smash. 

41 Comments

1. martha p -
Just a minor correction, Kylie's latest album is titled "X" (not "In my Arms" as you state in your commentary).

2. urias g -
Glad to see Kylie continue her run of Top Ten hits...do you think "In My Arms will peak at #10 or continue to rise like "Heartbreaker" by Will.I.Am and Chery Cole?

3. Salvo -
As a Cardiff City fan working and living in Dubai, it warms the cockles of my heart to see my beloved team become 'pop stars'.

4. çetin k -
why dont u talk about robyn ? Who's that girl is the best single of top 40.

5. mellberg2007 -
Great to follow your commentary James, thank you for your great updates and inside information - now and over the past years. Keep up the good work.

6. michael.aries -
Eurovision connection. Millwall FC's Oh Millwall is a reworking of Volare which was Italy's 1958 Eurovision Entry.

7. nli10 -
I'd only just got used to not visiting Dotmusic!

Thanks for the too many years to think about of chart stats. :)

8. James Masterton -
Ooh, now here is the first dilemma. If I've said something stupid like getting the title of Kylie's album wrong, do I correct the original entry or just leave the comments to pull me up?

How on earth did I fail to spot that?

9. macca7174 -
James,
A lot of people don't bother reading comments (it was only by chance I did), so I would suggest changing the original post, and putting a footnote to the copy detailing the amendment.

10. Matt -
Thanks for the update always throughly enjoy reading them every week, surprise Cold paly could achieve sucha high placing in the top 10 since so many was downlaoded free. Still not sure about Madonna's and Justin Timberlake's song '4 Minutes', it still yet to grow on me however everyone must like it since it's been there for the past 4 weeks, and how the hell has Scooter go to the top with their album? That is just shocking!

11. bencook2008 -
Hi James,

Looks like my prediction about will.i.am is proving correct. Although it's been available on iTunes for a week now, the Cheryl Cole remix is still only number 27 there, with the original album version at number 5. People are still downloading the wrong version by accident.

Ben

12. rickyalvers -
haha that mae me laugh about only just having got use to not going to dotmusic. I STILL type dotmusic to this day! Luckily still get redirected.

This is really cool though, I've always wanted to leave comments.

13. weskerslake -
James,

Thanks for the comments, as usual. Just one query - why do you only comment on the top 30 new entries? What about some info on Daddy-O by the Wideboys ft. Shaznay Lewis and LES Artistes by Santogold.

Regards, Wes

14. bloglover2008 -
I'm confused. i've been an avid JM chart commentary reader since i discovered you last year but you keep chopping and changing the site address about.
First it was uk.music.yahoo.com then uk.launch.yahoo.com/ and now new.uk.music.yahoo.com/blogs/chartwatch/ . can you please settle on ONE home and stay there. Sometimes the redirect links don't work and i end up struggling to find you. Don't you guys rbelieve in the old saying if it ain't broke why fix it?

15. -
Hi bloglover, there have been a few reasons why we've chopped and changed our URLs over the years, most of which are too boring to mention. Anyhow I'm sure with be on this new one for quite some time to come!

16. philmorg1 -
Very informative commentary as ever James. Perhaps you can enlighten me as to who on earth buys Kylie Minogue singles as the quality of them spirals ever downwards, and her voice becomes uncannily Minnie Mouse like. Her "Best International Female" Brit award at the expense of Rihanna was a joke - almost as big a joke, in fact, as Kate Nash's "Best British Female" Brit - the category in which the far more talented Amy Macdonald never even got nominated.The mind Boggles!

17. Brett -
At last I can make comments after reading this commentary (which I've enjoyed for years) Doesn't look like Ashley Simpson will do as well as she might've done guys... I got my Coldplay vinyl on my NME magazine and my eyes nearly popped out of their sockets when I saw the new Kylie single in my local ZAVVI on 7",Her first vinyl in 11 years! Needless to say I'm listening to it as we speak!

18. Richard H -
I wonder if Coldplay's 'Violet Hill' will be seen as a purely download-only release, considering that a physical version (no matter how limited edition it is) exists, free with the NME magazine.

19. brndtnlsn -
I like the new site and the comment feature. I hope you don't end up overwhelmed by it, James; I love your column. Personally, I think Coldplay are just trying to give you something to write about.

20. mebuscat -
Hi James, hope you will always continue posting your comments no matter what the url is! I follow you since ages (dotmusic, ...) and the new comment feature is cool :-) I also like that the comments are available as a rss feet !!! Thanks and keep up the good work.
Best wishes from germany
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Next »
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Andy Malt
14
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
11
Church of Dave
by Dave Henderson
32
Festival Blog
by Dr Clive Weather-Vane
3
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
12
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
10
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
23

Music Blog Archives

July 2008 (2)
June 2008 (5)
May 2008 (4)
Cheeky Girl miscarriage 'personal'
Press Assoc. -
Sun 20 Jul 2008 3:56PM BST
Press Assoc. - Revelations about Cheeky Girl Gabriela Irimia miscarrying politician Lembit Opik's baby should have been kept private, the singer's mother has said.
More »
More News Stories
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.