Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Week Ending September 13th 2008

Posted Mon 8 Sep 2008 7:56PM BST by James Masterton in Chart Watch UK

Before 2007 you would have had to scan the records as far back as 1995 to find a year with three different singles spending as long as five weeks each at the top. Instead we now find 2008 marking the second year in succession that the trio has been completed as 'I Kissed A Girl' joins 'Now You're Gone' and 'Mercy' in extending its run at the top into a second month.

What was theoretically going to be a titantic batttle for the very top of the singles chart eventually turned into a bit of a damp squib with Eric Prydz and 'Pjanoo' never looking likely to overhaul the Katy Perry juggernaut and give us an all too rare instrumental Number One hit. With both of the top two singles going physical, it was actually the Katy Perry single that surged in sales, the CD and vinyl versions of the Eric Prydz track barely lifting his sales at all.

The real threat to Katy Perry's crown lies just one place below as the biggest new hit of the week makes an instant Top 3 smash. Born from the famous Burlesque dance act, the Pussycat Dolls were transforming into singing superstars back in 2005 thanks to some clever choice of material and the swift realisation that frontswoman Nicole Scherzinger clearly had more to offer than just a nice pair of legs. First single 'Don't Cha' set the ball rolling by going straight to Number One in late 2005 and subsequently spending most of the next year on the chart, and was followed in short order by four more Top 10 hits including the drippy ballad 'Stickwitu' which followed their first hit to very top of the chart.

Now after a brief hiatus while Nicole attempted a misfiring solo run, the Pussycat Dolls are back to see if lightning can strike twice. Well if it hasn't it was a damn near miss. New single 'When I Grow Up' lodged itself at the top of the rankings of most of the online stores within a few hours of being made available and has ended the week as their fifth Top 3 hit with the potential for even greater things to come. The track itself follows their usual formula (or should that be lack of it), firing off in about seven different directions at once and neatly challenging all perceptions as to what an R&B hit should sound like. I'm tempted to suggest that Rodney Jerkins and his team of writers maybe should have spent a little more time giving the track an actual tune but there is no doubting that once again this is a single that makes you sit up and pay attention, something that I may have said many times before it really all you can ask of a worldwide smash hit single.

The PCDs are the only major activity in an otherwise only slightly adjusted Top 10, but once more the bottom half of the Top 20 is a different story. Miley Cyrus leads the way with her single 'See You Again' clearly still with sales to hoover up - the disturbingly faultless teen star charges 23-14 to make the Top 20 for the very first time in her career.

New at Number 16 are Gym Class Heroes with new single 'Cookie Jar', the lead track from a digital single marketed as the 'Patches From The Quilt EP' to herald the release of their new album 'The Quilt' which hits the shops later this month. The new hit is their first since the New York group made their British breakthrough in 2007 with the hits 'Cupid's Chokehold' and 'Clothes Off!', both singles memorably based around some famous hits of the past, although third single 'The Queen And I' was a mysterious flop, missing the main singles chart altogether despite a full physical release. The new single refreshingly moves away from the old hit recycled formula and allows the group to stretch their songwriting legs properly. Special guest on the single is The-Dream, aka singer and songwriter Terius Nash who could be forgiven for deciding to retire and never work again given that his name appeared on the credits for a certain song called 'Umbrella' which you might remember from last year.

Now to the single that lands at Number 17, which if you believe everything Radio One is telling you is the cult sensation of the summer and the track that has the whole nation dancing. Steve Mac's 'Paddy's Revenge' is one of those devastatingly simple ideas that works so well you wonder why everyone hasn't been doing it for years - taking what sounds like a traditional Irish reel and marrying it to some techno beats to conjure up an instant party smash hit. Almost overnight a popular meme has sprung up around the song, with people dancing to the song in the most unlikely of public places and uploading the resulting videos to YouTube. The music at the heart of the single is one of those pieces of music that is instantly familiar to many without anyone being aware of what it is actually called. 'Paddy's Revenge' is actually based on 'Music For A Found Harmonium' as performed by Irish band Patrick Street back in the 1980s. Their recording has been used on countless film soundtracks, TV commercials and as a backing for anything requiring an even vaguely Irish flavour to the extent that it is probably the most ubiquitous Irish jig in popular culture - all of which makes its transformation into a club track even more inspired. What is maybe more surprising given the level of hype attached to it is that the single has only made Number 17. Either this is a slow start for a track that is destined to become a cult classic, or once again the Radio One presenters queuing up to hype it to the hills have proved that they don't quite have their fingers on the pulse of popular culture to the extent they believe.

'Music For A Found Harmonium' of course predates even the famous Patrick Street recording, having been originally written by the late Simon Jeffes for the famous Penguin Cafe Orchestra. The works of the legendary jazz collective have spawned many covers, reinterpretations and cultural reference points over the years but precious few have ever been turned into proper pop hits. I was tempted to set a trivia quiz, asking which Britpop-era group used a PCO track as the inspiration for their most famous hit but the answer is actually far too easy to find - so step forward Spacehog who took 'Telephones And Rubber Bands' as the basis for their 1996 single 'In The Meantime'. Obviously you knew that already...

Just missing out on a Top 20 place is the lady who is one of the aforementioned five week Number One stars of 2008. Duffy has already proved that she is no one hit wonder with 'Warwick Avenue' having had a lengthy run at the top end of the singles chart, even with continual pressure from the still charting 'Mercy'. Now she seems set for a third big hit as 'Stepping Stone' charges to Number 21 this week. Although there was apparently some indecision as to what the third single proper from the album was to be ('Serious' under consideration at one point), the decision to go with 'Stepping Stone' makes sense given it was one of the most popular tracks when her album 'Rockferry' was released back in March, the track garnering enough solo sales to creep to the bottom end of the Top 100.

Ten places below at Number 31 is much lauded soul singer Bryn Christopher who makes his Top 40 debut with second single 'Smilin', this after debut hit 'The Quest' missed the Top 40 by inches earlier in the summer. Another powerfully voice star to rival established names such as Paulo Nutini and James Morrison, Christopher first came to people's attention thanks to support slots with Amy Winehouse (to whom he bears an eerie vocal resemblance) at the tail end of last year. A series of appearances on the undercard of several festivals this summer was clearly designed to push him to even greater things, so the rather lacklustre performance of his singles to date remains something of a puzzle.

Now we all love comebacks don't we? Few people would dispute that the celebrated reappearance of Take That two years ago made a great many people happy and even produced its fair share of classic singles along the way. Was anyone seriously awaiting the return of New Kids On The Block though? Well they are back regardless. The group were formed as teenagers at the tail end of the 80s by svengali Maurice Starr. After a stuttering start and an initial flop album they had a short but spectacular run of fame in the United States in 1989 and 1990 which also found its way to these shores, to the extent that they continued to have hits in the UK long after their stars had faded stateside. The group disbanded after attempts to go for a more adult market ended in failure in 1994 and perhaps surprisingly solo hits from the group were few and far between - a shame actually as Jordan Knight's 1999 single 'Give It To You' was a true guilty pleasure.

Their 2008 comeback follows several abortive attempts to persuade them to reunite in the past and I have to confess I'm watching the results with a kind of morbid curiosity. Check out 'Summertime' for yourself below. Number 34 first week out isn't exactly impressive, but there must still be some people out there hankering for the boys they had as pinups eighteen years ago, aren't there?

44 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
All good things come to those who wait.

2. James -
Hey everyone. How is it going?

Well worth the wait! great blog James! :)
Wow, a rubbish Top 10 2 weeks in a row, but the rest of the chart is quite interesting. Is Duffy's Stepping Stone fully available on Physical now?
Nice to see Gym Class Heroes at number 16... has that gone physical? If not, is it going to be?
Surprised and happy to see Keanes new song make a sudden rise 30-23. Can it scrape top 20? I hope so! :)
Plus "Far Away," by Nickelback has entered the top 100 now and it goes physical in a few weeks. It should be another Top 20 hit for them, and it is soooo much better than "Rockstar," and "Photograph," :)

3. joel -
Yup. I agree. Good blog!

Shame Eric Prydz's "Pjanoo" couldn't climb to no.1 this week. Here's hoping it break the record for most consecutive weeks at no.2!

It is quite a boring chart, isn't it? I'm liking Gym Class Heroes "Cookie Jar" - the melody's catchy and the lyrics are amusing.

4. Blog -
Re: comment 2 : Duffy's - Stepping Stone went physical last monday 1st August and Gym Class Heroes went physical TODAY monday 8th August so should climb at end of week. Jason Mraz missed the Top 100 entirely with Make It Mine and as for the OLD geezers on the block ..........it's no surprise they only made #34!

I sincerely hope PCDs don't make #1 with when i grow up............I can't stand it...........it's repetative boring [profane]e.

I'd really like to see Sam Beeton, The Metros, Sigur Ros, Cut Copy and Sonny J do well in this weekends forthcoming chart.

5. Yahoo! Music User -
Sorry James, but maybe the PCD single does fire off in seven different directions at once, but that's what makes it exciting and makes it stand head and shoulders above anything that Girls Aloud could come up with.

6. James -
Re: comment 4: Cheers for the info :)

7. Yahoo! Music User -
Interesting to see Katy actually sold more singles this week than she has done so far in a week now the song’s gone physical. And what about Noel Gallagher getting clobbered on stage? Was the whole thing set up for publicity?

8. James -
Does it ever annoy you when people criticise a music act for always sounding the same? You know, how someone buys an album and says that all the songs sound the same. I think the most recent example is Scouting For Girls. In lots of album reviews i've read, people criticise their songs for sounding exactly the same. Yes, they sound similar, but not EXACTLY the same. They also tend to exaggerate further and say the songs would still sound the same if you played, say, She's So Lovely over Elvis Ain't Dead...of course it wouldn't sound the same.
Anyways, what im trying to say is their music sounds similar because its called a style of music,, and a style of music they work best with, and its whats made them popular. If they had like, a mix of indie and hip hop songs on the album, it wouldn't flow as nicely when you listen to the tracks, and people would criticise the songs for sounding too different. lol Its what makes artists popular, keeping to the same style of music. Cascada, Snow Patrol amongst other examples of making songs that sound similar, but its whats made them popular right? Can you really imagine Usher going emo, or Scooter going country? lol it wouldn't sound right at all would it?
In conclusion, stop criticising artists ffoo souunding the same!

9. Yahoo! Music User -
If you have been trying to download your fav tracks from HMV and can't find them it's all due to them going to MP3! That's why they were not returning sales the other week too!
I asked them about it and they said that all the tracks that were on WMA DRM are going to be replaced....HOWEVER it's going to take 3 YEARS!!!!
They intend to build it up to SIX Million tracks too.
At the moment a lot of errors have crept into the site. Several tracks were priced at £99.99 for a single download!

If you ask me they have made a big error by deleting all the WMA files, before they replaced them with MP3.

10. Chris -
Yay for the Spacehog reference. I think they're due a revival anytime soon, especially now that they're back together.

ITM is one of those lost classics that everyone must have on their iPods.

11. Yahoo! Music User -
"When I grow up" is suitable only for 5-10 year olds. I don't understand how anyone above that age and with an IQ over 40 would stand listening to it. At least Katy Perry's song (although not much either) has a descent melody.

12. marcoonia -
Re Post #3.About staying at No 2 and not hitting the No 1.
Here are a list of singles that did just that:-
5 Weeks

Never Ending Song Of Love - New Seekers
Aug 7,14,21,28,Sep 4th 1971

4 Weeks

Vienna - Ultravox Feb 14,21,28 Mar 7 1981
Jeepster - T.Rex Dec 11,18,25,1971+Jan 1 1972
Pushbike Song - The Mixtures Feb 6,13,20,27 1971
Let's Dance - Chris Montez Nov 3,10,17,24 1962

Now you'll all be able to sleep at night. Anyone know any more?

13. DS -
Didn't Kylie and Jason spend forever at number 2 before getting to number 1 around Christmas 89.... oh, I reread the post *didn't* get to number 1. Ok got it. Someone was stuck at number 2 forever behind Bryan Adams... the memory's all a bit fuzzy now.

14. DS -
Or maybe it was Wet Wet Wet. Some American schmaltzy boy band song was number 2 for like 7 weeks I'm sure. I will remember it....

15. Yahoo! Music User -
Post 11 - I agree with you on this one. "When I Grow Up" is just horrendous. I liked the band's old stuff, I really do, but the song's got AWFUL lyrics, a TERRIBLE rythm and a BAD message. This can't get to no1! No way!

16. Yahoo! Music User -
runs at no2:

7 weeks All 4 One "I Swear" behind Wet Wet Wet's "Love Is All Around" in 1994

6 weeks Right Said Fred "I'm Too Sexy" behind Bryan Adams "Everything I Do.." in 1991

think there was a 6-weeker in the 1970's by a brass band?

did Kelis "Trick Me" spend 4 weeks at number 2 in 2003 and would that be the record this century for most weeks at no2 without getting to the top?

17. Yahoo! Music User -
"Save The Lies" down to number 81? What's the world coming to? Mind you, I always thought "Got No Place To Go" would have made a better single!

18. Tina -
Brighouse And Rastrick Brass Band made number 2 for 6-weeks with Floral Dance commencing 10/12/1977 and finishing on 14/01/1978. It was stuck behind Mull of Kintyre by Wings for that time which enjoyed a 9-week stay at number 1 and became the best selling UK single of all time before Band Aid took its title.(followed by Elton John). It is interesting to observe that most of the long stayers at Number 2 are held up by longer stayers at the top.

19. Regino -
A dull top 10 except for PCD selling like pancakes in internet (metaphor!) reaching no 3.

What in the world is happening to Save The Lies? That's gonna be like one of the most overlooked or underrated song in 2008!
Going downhill is an obvious result due to the lack of distributing.
Promoting? yep.
Airplay? yep.
But that's just until it's release. I have seen it in the adverts and heard it on the before it's release. I guess the AU-only single (Don't Wanna Go To Bed Now) might be next after this and we might see or hear this song again next year like Colbie Caillat's Bubbly (even though I never knew it's in 72 one week but now it's at 60!).

Stepping Stone might go up a lot next week. I think that's not the third single unless her very first one is not in her album.

What's with the criticism with PCD's song? It's good but it could be better a little.

There are 3 songs that spend 4 weeks at the top this year. American Boy, 4 Minutes and Dance Wiv Me.

20. Regino -
I forgot. Burlesque? I thought they're American (many of them to say not all [that includes Nicole]).

I kissed a girl is physical now, eh? What about 8 weeks at no. 1? That's gonna *bleep you off, isn't it?

...I have seen it in the adverts and heard it on (radio) the before it's release...
I forgot to type the word radio on it. lol
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jay-Z for BRITs

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 11:12AM GMT

Dotmusic - Rap don to perform medley at London bash More »

More News Stories