Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Katy Perry in Knife Controversy

Posted Wed 22 Oct 2008 11:46AM BST by Mitch Carter in The Guestlist

Pop sensation Katy Perry has caused outrage in the UK after a photo of her posing with a knife was discovered on the internet.

The picture was part of a series of photos taken to promote her debut album One of the Boys but was discarded as a leading image.

Perry who is best known for her single I Kissed A Girl which topped the UK charts earlier in the year, is still to comment on the picture.

Richard Taylor, father of knife victim Damilola Taylor, told The Sun newspaper "This woman's behaviour is unacceptable.

"She must be out of her mind to pose for a picture like this. There is nothing glamorous about knives - they wreck families."

What are your thoughts on the photograph? Is Katy at fault for posing with a deadly weapon or are media being too sensitive?  Could this picture influence young people to carry knives or is it  simply a harmless PR stunt?

 

691 Comments

141. hothunkydude -
I don't see the offense Katy has made posing with a knife.If anything I believe it sends out the message-Protect yourself and Richard Taylor the Knife victim father is being too damn sensitive.

142. Yahoo! Music User -
that's not a knife...

143. Garry -
She's got what she wanted, loads of publicity.

144. Simon -
All the dumb comments about chefs on tv are from complete philistines who obviously dont know jack about PR or real life. Chefs are trained in using knifes, do u see G Ramsay using a 3 inch knife near his eye and posing? Of course not he would use a meat cleaver or carving knife because he is a trained professional. 3 inch knife is bad? WHY? Cause it is concealable and is being wielded by a pop singer who has no culinary skills to show off. Lets say it was a pair of scissors instead what do u think that would interpret? Cutting yourself? Depression for young girls? etc . Its just plain wrong.

145. Husain F -
lol. well my first reaction was for ppl to get a life lol. howvever, although not the only reason dat could lead to knife crime, i can see why it may encourage youths to go out with a knife.

146. Wayne -
Its perfectly straightforward. The girl is dumb, just like everyone that carries a knife. It cannot glamourise anything as there is nothing glamourous about this pointless photo.

147. Yahoo! Music User -
I can not belive some of the comments on here regarding the knife pose. Any one with decency would have said no to this sort of image. If some people on here think its cool then your living in different world. to many lifes have been lost this year alone. the comment regarding the knife and fork o dear you really are stupid

148. Charlotte -
ooh please ..gimee a break ..next they will be saying her song promotes homosexual activity ..sheeesh the real issue here is ..sum people need to get a life and stop looking for these pictures ..yeaah knife crime is an issue ..but its not like shes holding the knife at sum1 and planning on killing them ..i think we should jest ignore the tabloids needs to make money off peoples pain!!

149. Deb -
In my opinion the media are too sensitive in this case.
I know that knives are not something to take lightly in general...but this is a bit much.

don't people have better things to do than make something like this scandelous, when millions of people are being killed with knives, not taking a picture of someone holding one.
Seriously...there are far worse things going on than a popstar holding a knife... she could be cutting up her dinner ;)

150. Robert D -
whats the problem? She is posing with a knife and she looks damn sexy. What because katy perry has a knife we are all gonna start a stabbing frenzy? c'mon please sort ur heads out!!

151. Robert D -
whats the problem? She is posing with a knife and she looks damn sexy. What because katy perry has a knife we are all gonna start a stabbing frenzy? c'mon please sort ur heads out!!

152. kenny -
holding a knife in the context of cooking is hardly the same as portraying the image that it is cool to carry a knife.

again yahoo have published this why dont they withdraw it?

153. Robert D -
whats the problem? She is posing with a knife and she looks damn sexy. What because katy perry has a knife we are all gonna start a stabbing frenzy? c'mon please sort ur heads out!!

154. Richard -
If a photo was taken of me with a knife cutting food in a kitchen is bad, what is the world coming to, Does anyone complian about Mr Ramsey when he is swinging his knife about in the kitchen!!!! get a bloody grip

155. ma a -
A very clever publicity stunt I never heard of her till this article she will probably sell more records.

156. Sara-Jane -
Well, I do not like her as an artist, she irritates me, but this was not her fault. She would have posed for pictures that she was told to right? But whoever thought this was a good idea do need to be brought up about this, it was not a clever idea. With us having such a high knife crime problem, people were of course going to be angry about this. But then on the flip side, it is the idiot who is carrying a knife and thinking it is ok to do so that is the issue, not the knife itself.

157. razell -
p.s ....no one would have seen this pic of her with a knife..not unless they put it on yahoo front page or something.. ...d'oh :X ty yahoo for showing a larger amount of ppl this pic :)

158. Peter -
I think Katy Perry is awesome, the fact that sha has a picture with a knife just shows she's got a dark side, and everyone who wants to damn her for the sake of one picture needs to be chokeslammed!

159. colin -
thats a hundred percent YES.

160. Jordan -
How stupid are sme of you people!

Yes the photo is very insensative, but firstly the idea for this picture probably wasnt her's, she may have been a little nieve letting them do it, but thats not a shootable offence.

Second off all they realised this picture was misleading so DIDNT release it. And on to my 3rd point this isn't a released publication by Katy or her advisors this has just been leaked out.
Page:  4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
195
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Doherty's "heart stopped"

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 1:07PM GMT

Dotmusic - Babyshambler reveals life support drama More »

More News Stories