Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

Beyonce Steals Songwriter From Leona

Posted Wed 5 Nov 2008 11:13AM GMT by Mitch Carter in The Guestlist
Simon Cowell was left reeling today after Beyonce recorded a song that was originally intended for Leona Lewis.

The track called ‘Halo' was written for Leona by Ryan Tedder, lead singer for soft-pop act One Republic, who also wrote Leona's transatlantic smash ‘Bleeding Love'.

Cowell was said to be shocked by the news that Beyonce had recorded the track as he had previously agreed with Tedder that the song would be recorded by Leona.

An insider at SongBMG, Leona's record label, said: "Leona's diary is so rammed it didn't look like she could record it until next year. Ryan didn't want to hang around so he gave it to Beyonce".

Although it's hard to fault Beyonce for wanting to perform the track, I can't help thinking that the song would suit Leona's tones a lot more. Listen to Beyonce's version of the track below and let us know who you would prefer to hear sing 'Halo'.

1815 Comments

141. Yahoo! Music User -
Leona has a much more beautiful voice and this song would have suited her more. Beyonce is so over-rated its annoying!

142. tom -
oh now my ears hurt! had to turn right down i didnt like it but leona would be better to screachy

143. KunmiO -
Leona should have sang this song

144. Darren -
Good!!! I cant stand her...especially after she couldnt even show up for her Mobos!

145. Yahoo! Music User -
Havent a clue who either of them are so it makes no difference to me !!

146. Yahoo! Music User -
i would prefer leona performing,its just sound normal,just need high speech which leona is good at.sorry byonce

147. charmaine -
beyonce sounds great as usual

148. oggdogg89 -
she seemed to sing a load of bum notes, leona would of been my choice

149. JL -
leonas voice ust have suited the song much better,i am not particularly a fan of beyonce and she didnt sound good at all.You couldnt ake out a lot of the words.

150. Imi -
Good God, I turned it off what crap!!!
Leona would have sung it not screached it!

151. Yahoo! Music User -
How do you know Leona would do it any better ?

You cant presume it would be any good with her doing it.

If this was the other way round there would be hundreds of people saying Beyonce would have done a better job

If you were the songwriter would you hold on to the song for them? bear in mind he gets paid to write them, Business is business, you have to make money.

If simon wanted the song for leona then he should have done the decent thing and paid for the song now and kept it back for when she wasnt busy

152. ally m -
have to sat would much prefer to listen to leona it just doesnt suit beyonce's voice...no dont like it :(

153. GARY802 -
Leona Lewis 100% would sound a million times better! The answers obvious anyway it was wrote for the girl

154. S -
awww have to say shoulda gone to leona as im english lol:D Go leona! but dnt diss Beyonce singing coz u prob cant do any better:D

155. Donna -
The lyrics of this song require an almost angelic tone of voice to do it justice, Leona would have sung it faultlessly and efortlessly. Shame!

156. Baby-shiv -
I dont persinally think that beyonce can sing, she had talent ages ago now its gone and i think she is clinging onto the coat tail of fame!
She doesnt sing she shouts, leona has a pure voice, that has power without having to shout ! So I'm all for leona singing this!

157. rachael kerry -
shocking!!

158. aiping -
it aint that bad~~but dunno if it was compared leona would sing better for this song~~cos she has got a high pitched voice and just like forgive me song she did very well and ofcos bleeding love too :)

159. Yahoo! Music User -
Sounds good to me. Beyonce or Leona - who cares - they both are similar (ish).... I agree with Gem - if you snooze ..... you loose (Leona).

160. Yahoo! Music User -
I honestly think that this song is really good sung by B but it is defo a leona lewis orinataed song, it's way 2 clean and that's leano's musical style so i say good effort by beyonce but should really be sung by Leaona.
Still a really good song!
Page:  4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
a-CMU-blog
by Chris Cooke
396
Chart Watch UK
by James Masterton
127
Down The Front
by Reviews Editor
49
Recommenders
by Reviews Editor
41
Snap, Crackle and Pop
by Dave Rumour
194
The Guestlist
by Mitch Carter
88
This Day In Music
by Neil Cossar
336
Touching The Void
by Johnny Famethrowa
227
Video Premieres
by The Editor
43

Most Comments

Jay-Z for BRITs

Dotmusic -
Tue 24 Nov 2009 11:30AM GMT

Dotmusic - Rap don to perform medley at London bash More »

More News Stories